What's wrong with self criticism? It seems like a good idea to reflect on yourself...

What's wrong with self criticism? It seems like a good idea to reflect on yourself, but it always seems like it gets abused for bullying and degredation.

Attached: Peng_4.jpg (261x382, 17.3K)

Other urls found in this thread:

m.youtube.com/watch?v=M7Z5U9G8D-o
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

Reminds me of self-flagellation without the spiritual benefits. Also a socialist state allowing people to self-crit in lieu of executions is a lot different than a shitty first world maoist book group that tries to force its members to "self-crit" whenever they disagree with whatever rapist is running the group at that moment.

You literally just described the pros and cons of self crit.

yeah but I wanted stalin tier apologetics but for mao

I would like to see bourgeoisies doing public self criticism in the Stalinist trial fashion

Self-crit is literally cult shit. Pushing members to internalize any disagreement or friction with the leadership as some sort of personal flaw and repent in some act of public self-flaggellation is an actual part of cult psychology. This sort of shit is why Maoists rarely get anywhere and their groups usually end in disaster.

Killing your own members is good political Praxis!!!
Made by UNITED RED ARMY GANG

m.youtube.com/watch?v=M7Z5U9G8D-o

You used the wrong pic

Attached: 9d5d9712e43dd4661df768e8bdb49a3d0310d740cef40b6078306a97ed111e64.jpg (600x350, 126.17K)

nothing

Attached: maoism.png (1024x4584, 2.41M)

What sort of ⛏️rotskyist-Third Worldist shit is this?

Self criticism is a core of a communist organization.
If someone wants to be called a member of the party, he has to recognize his mistakes and try to change his future behavior.
Disagreements with the party line can not be considered mistakes in a healthy party, as long as they do not disrupt party action.
Democratic centralism is the only coherent method of organization, members can't put their self interest or ego above the party. Open discussion in the organization but unity in action.

*Grabs icepick

Attached: 5b794b306dd4acaec72c83427f7e8f7df370afdd4a1266bc8b9e9ea7ed56604a.jpg (255x255, 18.96K)

While global socialism is our goal, initiating wars with all capitalist nations will only alienate the proletariat of both your and the capitalist counties and lead to either a coup or a slaughter.

During the French bourg revolution, France basically was at war with ever single Euro nation. It's inevitable.

Maybe to make self-crit useful we must start applying it primarily to people in authority.

We don't use single shot rifles in the modern age

If you have ever called anyone a faggot, now is the time to self criticize ITT and explain how you will move past your transgression.

Shut up faggot

You pretty much answered your own question, OP.

Self-criticism is scientific. You can't just do and say stuff without reflecting on your actions and the results you got. The point of self-crit is to say, "here's what went wrong and why, I'll avoid it next time and here's what I should do instead."
The other aspect of self-crit is that a party has to keep people somewhat in line, you can't just expel people every time they fuck up, or keep out everyone with a bad record. So you get them to self-crit to make sure they understand what they did wrong and know how to change.

because it ends up turning into sectarianisst bullshit based on personal agenda or opinion rather than logic and data.

This. Self crit should be reserved for actions that lead to a clear failure, not ideological/theoretical disagreements. If you fail to keep your mouth shut and a comrade gets arrested, or if you drop the ball on your duties and an important task doesn’t get done, that’s the time for self crit. Not for when you think that trans bathrooms are idpol tripe and the party thinks it’s a worthwhile cause.

Stalin is one of the greatest men to have ever lived on this earth, and the USSR was the greatest civilization that ever existed. Fuck you, go masturbate to the rapture faggot.

Imagine being this delusional. Stalin was a great leader in many ways, and the USSR accomplished many great things, but let’s not degenerate into hyberbole.

Self-crit is not a Maoist invention you brainlet.
Also Stalin and Mao are two of the greatest heroes in history.

why would any of them selfcrit though? self-criticizing is humiliating, and doing it only further cements the image of you as guilty. people who actually deal with the court of public opinion know you should always deny, apologizing never helps you. the only people who would actually self-criticize are naive or would get bullied or threatened into it.

Have you ever been in a position of responsibility where people depend on you? Being able to recognize when you mess up is a necessary part of real leadership.

did Mao ever self-criticize?

yeah he did, so did lenin and stalin and so on

Can you link me the text? disclaimer, I don't give a shit about Stalin, just mao.