Is CG animation better for cartoons, or is hand-drawn animation better, Zig Forums?
Is CG animation better for cartoons, or is hand-drawn animation better, Zig Forums?
Luke Moore
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
myredditnudes.com
twitter.com
Tyler Wilson
both are good
Christopher Torres
I think Doug Walker should be removed
Joseph Garcia
Both are good if done right but hand drawn tends to look prettier.
Asher Perez
Depends on subject and individual quality, retard.
Justin White
Who gives a shit? If you enjoy watching either one then it doesn't matter.
Jason Gonzalez
>spongebob has tiny holes inside of his bigger holes
terrifying
Isaac Watson
I’m almost entirely a 2D purist, but if it has good aesthetics, I do not mind.
Alexander Jenkins
this. movies like Hotel Transylvania and Spider-Verse using 2D sensibilities and exaggeration in 3D are a great happy-medium.
Caleb Stewart
Depends on how well rendered the CG. As 3D tech improves older CG can look weird and dated, which isn't something 2D has to worry about unless the art itself is bad.
Camden Flores
The medium never matters when the concepts are SHIT. Especially annoying infantile garbage like Minions or Spongebob. And Disney also makes shit, they're the reason that western animation is infantile trash.
Blake Howard
Don’t let Doug anywhere near SpongeBob, he wouldn’t get it!
Blake Ross
>my mr. enter thread is removed but this is still up
Fuck the jannies
Dylan Howard
CGI is a little closer to heaven
Austin Lopez
Stylized CG has a lot of potential that I feel the industry has only scratched the surface of.
Jonathan Phillips
Chads appreciate both, however CGI movies typically look severely outdated every few years while 2D ages like wine.
Michael Myers
But user... so do real sponges.
Wyatt Morgan
Both do things the other one cant, turning 2D to 3D is retarded though.
Matthew Wood
I'll give you the classic asshole reply: it depends.
A big issue I feel with CG is that too often it's used for realism, which kinda misses the point of animation as an artform, but it's more to do with how it's used than its potential.
Juan Harris
It's a lot easier to get strong shapes out of a 2D drawing. While 3D models can easily be squashed and stretched, you have to make sure the CG model doesn't clip into the environment or other characters.
Nostalgia Critics video on it is alright, but he gives the impression that 2D animation is rare to see, even on TV. He never mentions that 2D animation is cheaper than 3D when it comes to TV.
Michael Peterson
This
Jaxson Cooper
>posting C.U.CK WALKER
>POSTING C.U.CK WALKER!!!!
Have people not learned, that fucker is DEAD, FOREVER.
Wyatt Lopez
So how was the actual video?
William Gray
its subjective and depends 100% on the vision of the director and what the studio wants to do.
Caleb Scott
Joshua Fisher
Pretty balanced, talking about the pros and cons of both.
Grayson Powell
Atleast post the link
youtube.com
Blake Roberts
WHERE DOES THE BLOCK COME FROM?
Isaac Richardson
Seconded. There are good stylized characters here and there like The Incredibles, but I'm really burnt out on 3D movies as of late. Nothing tops the facial expressions of good 2D animation.
Aaron Nelson
I'm one of the weirdos who just wants to see more stop-motion animation.
James Myers
YOU AUTHORIZED PAYMENT ON THE DOUG WALKER POLICY?!
Logan Long
I prefer this video format over NC
How is it weird to want more of something that is sparse?