Let’s have a comfy thread where we discuss Berserk, Vinland Saga and Vagabond; the three main hard shonen. Punpunbros and Kingdombros are welcome too
The Big 3 Hard Shonen
Gavin Richardson
Other urls found in this thread:
Mason Cox
Vagabond is seinen/psuedo hard seinen. Made in Abyss and Kingdom are my favorite hard shounen though; Berserk has too many boring shounen tropes like "the power of friendship" for me to like it.
Blake Flores
You’re just resentful and bitter because you have no friends so you think the power of friendship is unrealistic.
Asher Johnson
stop with this fucking hard and light shit holy fuck
HxH is classified as a shounen
Berserk is classified as a seinen
there is no fucking hard shounen and light seinen
kill yourself
Colton Gomez
>hard shounen
When will this meme die?
David Davis
kingdom is my fav manga right now but it has a lot of "power of friendship" that you hate lol
Carter Diaz
>HxH is classified as a shounen
>Berserk is classified as a seinen
source?
Elijah Price
Their magazines. Their use or disuse of furigana.
Eli Scott
This is your average Zig Forums poster , remember this.
Colton Jones
So no source. Gotcha.
Ian Hill
>why yes, I like both my seinen and josei al dente, how could you tell?
Jeremiah Perry
hakusensha.co.jp
Young Animal is listed under "seinen manga magazines".
Christian Edwards
It's in a seinen magazine, but the manga itself is not a seinen.
Jacob Ortiz
>it's in a seinen magazine
>it doesn't often use furigana
>it's known for its adult content
>but it's not seinen because I'm the one that defines what words mean
Adrian Rogers
sex and rape =/= seinen. Being a seinen comes from the themes that the manga tackles. The reason HxH is seinen while Berserk isn't is due to Berserk being rather childish with its themes, while Hunter X Hunter has some depth to it.
Adrian Anderson
B-Based HunterChad!
Nathan Ward
I knew it was a hunterfag. I mentioned two other criteria just besides "sex and rape". But you can stay in your delusional world if you want to.
Robert Perez
Please don't compare Vagabond to fairy shit and Trannyland Saga
Christian Bennett
You're literally fucking retarded, holy shit!
Easton Bennett
Seinen is defined by th magazine it's published in, you moron.
>The reason HxH is seinen while Berserk isn't is due to Berserk being rather childish with its themes, while Hunter X Hunter has some depth to it.
Holy fucking kek
Carson Walker
>3 shounenshitters seething while having no arguments
Typical.
Adam Phillips
>No argument
Not them but you proved yourself to be a retard.
Colton Bell
damn son
Elijah Hughes
>hunterfag shonenshitter thinks I read shonen manga
But since you constantly deny reality I guess you'd just say all the seinen manga I read is shonen to make yourself feel better
Mason Lopez
Seinen/shounen is literally the target audience you fucking mong
Berserk is published in a magazine targeted towards older audiences, therefore it's a seinen manga.
Now fuck off back to your containment thread
Aiden Gutierrez
you really went all out
Luis Reyes
>hunterfag shonenshitter thinks I read shonen manga
Well, you are defending Berserk (a shounen manga)
Mason Smith
>This thread
kek get dabbed on huntertard
Logan Jenkins
>Berserk (a shounen manga)
Dominic Smith
Berserk is seinen for the same reasons K-ON or Dungeon Meshi are seinen. I'm not "defending" Berserk in particular I'm telling you what makes something seinen and that Berserk fits that criteria.
Thomas Roberts
You are stupid. In the end, the only thing that matters for the classification of a work is where it is published. Not the content. Does not matter how pseudo philosophical, sexual, viaolent or gritty it is. It is in a shonen magazine, it is a shonen. Azumanga Daioh and fucking Haganai and Luck Star are considered seinen.
Ryder Morgan
Are you the guy from the other thread? Azumanga Daioh and Lucky Star are both in shonen magazines. I don't know what Haganai is but it's probably also shonen since you seem to have no idea what you're talking about.
Jack Bell
Berserk is closer to moe garbage than it is seinen. Fuck off, shounenshitters.
Luis Hernandez
A lot of moe is seinen though.
Actually I just looked up Lucky Star and it seems like it's switched magazines a lot. And some of them are a combination of shonen and seinen manga and I think some of them may have been seinen magazines too. So I guess Lucky Star can't really be considered either one or the other. AD is shonen though.
Dominic Cox
True. a lot of moe slice of life are in seinen magazines. It does not matter that much. Only where is published. The content is completely fine. But I guess in Shonen Jump will never show characters having sex on screen. That is for sure.