Anime can't work in live actio

anime can't work in live actio.....

Attached: d8c2b3c3a21e018b44570fa361eac9e3.jpg (451x750, 39.09K)

>Anime can't work
FTFY

this was a pretty decent action flick ngl

You've made this thread already, and it wasn't in the favor of your argument despite some people conceding EoT and Alita were okay adaptations. Don't push your luck.

The only people who disagree are autistic weebs who think everything should be as 1:1 as possible.

But All You Need Is Kill was originally a book.

>ngl
Kill yourself.

Why this work?
because is a total original movie instead of a bad copy of what there is in the manga.

If you watched these back to back, you would call one a blatant rip off. The only differences are superficial.

So the novel came first, then the film, then the manga? Or was it novel, manga and film?

Emily Blunt would have made for a better Motoko Kusanagi

Attached: GiTS Major 2.jpg (1920x1080, 165.52K)

If you rip out

>the characters
>the Japanese references
>clunky dialogue

Then yes it can work. I'm just not sure what's left resembles the source material. Even that movie has an entirely different feel compared to the source.

OLD BOY also comes from a manga, and it's pretty shit. But it's also not your typical weeb/otaku manga with high school shit.

Attached: Old Boy (2).png (800x1155, 234.67K)

Second one.

I don't watch western movies, what is this supposed to be?

>It works perfectly if you change everything about it aside from the most basic aspects of the premise.

All You Need is Live Die Repeat

Attached: 3d.webm (1916x796, 2.94M)

Edge of Tomorrow, it's really good give it a watch.
That's not true user, the basic structure of the plot is still there with a few adjustments only the ending is drastically different.

The Hollywood ending was shit, but I suppose you can't have a blockbuster without a happy ending.

That movie was further proof that Tom Cruise is an amazing actor, as long as he gets to exclusively play Tom Cruise

Edge of All You Need is Live Die Tomorrow Repeat

Attached: 1555241851093.webm (274x468, 207.38K)

There is literally nothing wrong with a happy ending.

This, at some point, you've have to had enough of anime's edginess and nhilism, let the hero have his happy ending for fuck's sake.

>gits is good, he says as drool flies from his lips

What a disgrace that flick was.

Action*

Tom Cruise was pretty great in this. I liked the sleaziness of the MC, especially compared to how dull he was in the manga

>nly the ending is drastically different.
>MC isn't fresh out of boot camp
>Rita isn't young as hell because she lied to the government to enlist
>Mimics aren't bloated starfish
>mimics don't launch an attack on the base
>rita doesn't have a cute indian techie assistant
>Keiji doesn't train with the seargant or pick up any of Rita's mannerisms and skills through hundreds of loops
>Omega exists instead of just server mimics
>all the other side characters are replaced with generic military squad of red shirts
>Keiji doesn't paint his mech blue in the end to symbolize the sky Rita longed for

>>Rita isn't young as hell because she lied to the government to enlist
We're never told Rita's past for all we know it's the same as the manga, she "lies" about her middle name, so she's clearly hiding something
>>Mimics aren't bloated starfish
Anime aesthetics don't work in real life and it's superficial anyway
>>rita doesn't have a cute indian techie assistant
She has awkward male scientist friend
>>Keiji doesn't train with the seargant or pick up any of Rita's mannerisms and skills through hundreds of loops
He trains with Rita herself which is even better.
>>Keiji doesn't paint his mech blue in the end to symbolize the sky Rita longed for
They get to be together which is better

I watched it the first time not knowing the he was an adpation but having read the manga
And i got weird deja vu all along and i keep asking my family if we didnt already watched it before
Then when i checked the Wikipedia i saw they were both adaptation from the same novels
Movie is so underrated and its even better than the manga

This kino is superior to the anime unironically

Attached: DRAGONBALL_EVOLUTION.jpg (1961x2897, 1.44M)

when is she going to play Samus

That body is gross. Her chest is so flat, it actually makes her waist look fat.

Flat is Justice

thanks to this turd they didnt rape a lot more of others kino ip

>We're never told Rita's past
She clearly looks middle aged and the LN makes it clear she looks young already which causes most people to question her actual age. Contrast this with the actress who portrays Rita in the in-universe movies for the LN
>Anime aesthetics don't work in real life
And yet science fiction has been making bizarre creatures a thing since before even CGI.
>and it's superficial anyway
It's a change from the source material and impacts how the mimics fight. They fired off spines not charging people to maul them.
>She has awkward male scientist friend
Still a change, and he's not a cute indian scientist
>He trains with Rita herself which is even better.
It's debatable if it's better. I don't like it. Either way, it's a change from the LN
>They get to be together
And you can have your crappy hollywood ending where everything works out despite it being a contradiction of all the setup to that moment

Could a live-action adaptation of Lain work?

Attached: lain_iwakura_cosplay__1__by_volupture_cos_d93aent-fullview.jpg (1024x683, 149.53K)

EoT was better than the source material