Which is better?

Which is better?

Attached: 992207C0-18B6-4E2A-9DAB-EF2D54A4CCFE.jpg (2880x3600, 2.11M)

anything is better than monogatari

/thread
top is a decent story.
bottom is braindead fap material for waifufaggots.

Katana.
Mono is awful haremshit.

There is no point comparing them. It's like the powerlevel of vampires in Monogatari or legendary noble phantasms in Fate. It's infinite and uncountable.
What matter's is both are better than 99.99% of all anime.

what the fuck is at the bottom ?

Bottom is a pretentios low buget artsy coomer b8 harem, top is actually good.

>story with a clear beginning, middle, and ending, consistent themes, and complete character arcs
>mess that goes on as long as it keeps making money
I'll let you decide.

I haven’t watched either of them but top is samuraishit so it’s worse by default. Samuraishit is worse than isekai and I’m sick of people fellating it. They’re all the same.

Attached: 64f2c9a0.jpg (743x1049, 359.32K)

Do I need to watch the bottom first before the top?

Attached: The_Tatami_Galaxy.jpg (680x1000, 152.86K)

It's a deconstruction of samuraishit

Both are great but Monogatari is without a doubt better.

Why compare ? They are two completely different shows.

What with the sudden hate against monogatari on Zig Forums?

Katanagatari is objectively better.

>sudden
didn't people use to spam Bake threads with gore like eleven years ago

We've always had plebs who get filtered, but obviously there are more of them now that we have more normalfags.

Same author, same style of dialogue, they are plenty comparable.

Top is for intellectuals.
Bottom is for coomers.
Its simple, really.

Katanagatari is better because it has a clear end, and a definite moving on from what it was. Bakemonogatari doesn't end, it has an open ending which isn't really an ending at fucking all. Is the ending when they graduate? Is the ending the time skip? Katangatari is the better contained story. Bakemonogatari, is a meme random fuck where nothing feels complete, just moments of over coming predicaments until the next one shows up.

>-oomer
Hang yourself.

Zaregoto>Katana>Monogatari

Monogatari is too hit or miss for me. I really don't like Shinobu or Hachikuji arcs at all.
Really low lows, but also high highs.

Katanagatari, easily

The longer it goes, the more people realize the monogatari series is shit outside of Bake.

ThisCan't believe I used to like that overrated shit.

You haven't actually watched Monogatari. It has just as much of an ending. The only difference is that Nisio decided to write more stories about what happens to some of the characters afterwards. He could just as well have written something about Shichika's travels with Hitei, it doesn't really have any effect on the main story and how it concludes.
Honestly, even though I like Katanagatari's ending, Monogatari's is better and more satisfying.

whOA added to my sweet 3x3 xD

Why did Zig Forums hate it that much?

It wasn't dime a dozen moeshit or shounentrash

Same reason Zig Forums hates anything, it’s popular.