This is what rezeros author says about isekai haters

What's the deal with Hylics and their adjectives?

>is literally “another world” each different from the last

All isekai stories are the same!

Attached: SamFlam background.png (137x155, 25.96K)

An editor is a co-creator. Imagine being so ineffectual that you would disassociate from your work to cope.

Final fantasy 10

The biggest and most important difference is usually the ability of the author. Even if getting less generic settings and events more often would be nice, that's usually not the biggest flaw.

I think it's funny, he's obviously taking the piss

>All isekai stories are the same
this. It even came from him lmao

They're all the same because people are lazy and want to cash in on the craze, so they all make half-assed pieces of shit, or the light novel writer is an otaku/neet/dropout with shit taste or bad writing w/e combination and they got assigned an artist to draw for them

>ywn be a fat otaku shut-in that lives in your grandma's basement writing light novels about the demon girl that you self insert as making millions a year off of other people's work and shit taste

I see the same thing in the RPG Maker community. I wonder if they're related because it's also connected to Degica/Kadokawa.

There's individuals that fancy themselves the authorities. The curators. And they insist they know what people think of RPG Maker games. But point a finger at them, like, "How do you let that happen"? That shuts them up.

Zig Forums absolutely obliterated.
There's no recovering from that one.

True, but after a while when the market gets saturated people will mentally block out even the well written pieces unless they distinguish themselves enough.

I know I do when I see the isekai tag.

people are translating less of them now too. i remember when the craze was going on we'd get 50 new isekai chapters in a day, all of them absolute garbage.

Wishing a genre to be less generic is like saying "pretentious" is a bad thing.
It's like saying 'How dare they try to be something without my recognition and approval first."

Sin's Spira was confirmed to be an actual place far out at the sea, so it's not an isekai.

>The stories are different because the characters are different!
Are isekaifags this delusional?

Except there's nothing about isekai that makes it have to usually be in the standard fantasy world. I like many of them, but there's no reason there can't be more in other settings.

Imagine someone that does quality assurance that was purely subjective. "Quality" meaning "I like it, so everyone else will too."

>muh slow life
>muh nip culture
>muh rice
>muh onions sauce
>muh crop rotation
>muh im pacifist even though ive just genocided an entire country
>muh modern sensibilites, slavery is a ok though
>muh adventurers guild
>muh vidya game skill interface
>muh op skills
>muh every single female wants my dick because im "nice"
there i just described like 99% of all isekais out there

>CGDCT anime has different girls therefore they're all not the same

>i-it's not plagiarism
>t-they're all different
>really
this is what happens when you don't have likeness copyright laws

A caveman teaches spaceman how to make fire by rubbing sticks together.
>Yaoi Isekai.

>not all Isekai
Literally muh "not all women".
Isekai yourself.

Gotta give props to a guy that enjoyed Mushoku Tensei and then went to build his own successful series. Re:Zero's certainly iterative of the genre, but nonetheless he's added his own flare to it and people generally enjoy it.

>another thread of faggots attempting to join cool kids club by parroting shits without knowing isekai

This is what happens when you don't beat autism out of the impudent. They'll attempt to waste the court's time by telling the judge to enforce his interpretation of law and order.

He's both right and wrong. If you don't strive to be novel at the very least, you're not going to hook your readers. Especially if premises and themes are re-used. Isekai's usually have some of the following
>Cheat power
>Village
>Busty elves (I love em but it is what it is)
>Status
>Pompous jobber
>Rapey noble
>Adventurer guild
>Harem
>Monarchy like Kingdom
>Demon King vs God/Holy Being
We know that different people will think up of different stories and different characters will make the story flow in different ways. But you cannot help but see similarities, so what matters is execution. Re:Zero executes the whole fantasy game setting by putting a setting of realism in a world of game-like fantasy against a realistic protagonist with a game like ability. The whole "game" aspect is pretty much secondary and not in your face (looking at you status screens and skills), plus the way Subaru has to struggle to achieve his goals is a stark contrast to the escapist nature of these stories. Look at Mondaiji too, it pretty much has most of the elements of an isekai story but its executed so damn well that I actually forget from time to time that it is an isekai story.

Imagine you get isekai'd and it's literally a different world that doesn't resemble ours in any way.
No humanoid characters you could potentially mate with.
All creatures use senses different to ours, no way to communicate with them at first.
They are sulfur based instead of carbon based so the food tastes bad and everything smells of rotten eggs.

What would you do?

When are we gonna get the Eva or Madoka of isekai?

That sounds like a unique premise for an isekai. Add your classic tropes but then he's not able to execute most of them because the world is too damn incompatible for a being like him.

Can you demonstrate your understanding of a narrative?
Can you tell us how you would purpose to group like things, if not by their likeness?
Can you prove you're not retarded?

>character development is hard so the writers would rather shit out new characters endlessly.
I blame Kubo for this

Well OBVIOUSLY, the kingdom names are different, so they're completely different worlds, DUH!