How bad does artwork have to be for you to drop a manga?
How bad does artwork have to be for you to drop a manga?
Jaxon Foster
Xavier Murphy
Much like Tokyo Ghoul the art style starts shitty but ends up being pretty good.
This differentiates it from a series where the style is good at the start and ends up worse at the end (Naruto) or simply loses all soul (Bleach). Or one that had shitty art at the start and still does (One Piece)
Luis Miller
Attack on Titan "improved" artwork still doesn't look professional
Adam Green
>artfags
Asher Watson
Comics are a visual medium
Christian Allen
>comics
Matthew Smith
yes
Connor Cox
When it gets in the way of understand what's going on.
Lucas Cook
I dont mind bad chara design. Shit like old shoujo manga paneling is what I hate the most
Joseph Foster
Bland artwork is worse than bad artwork, not to mention story + paneling can carry a manga very hard. I’d rather read Mob Psycho 100 or Claymore over any generic isekai or romcom with no backgrounds
Bentley Morris
>Shit like old shoujo manga paneling is what I hate the most
yeah this bugs me too. everyone is like floating around
Parker Green
If it is worse than the beginning volumes of Elfen Lied.
John Powell
>reading manga with shit art in the first place
Haha...
Adrian Hughes
Is there a manga where the writing is so good that the shit art doesn't bother you?
Zachary Nguyen
Very bad. Still, I finished SS Episode G but didn't bother with the sequel.
Nathaniel Adams
Just watch the anime. SnK manga art is trash.
Jayden Myers
when it's nonexistent
Jaxon Allen
what light novel is this?
Gabriel Torres
>people will say SnK looks bad when Baki exists
yes your manga looks like shit
no I will not acquire your taste
Ayden Cruz
As long as I can understand what is happening it is alright. So SnK is passable, but Sam8 had to be dropped.
Robert Edwards
I'll never drop a manga I'm already reading because of the art, but I won't pick up manga if the art is bad
Isaac Gray
wrong board marveltranny
Anthony Long
Average. I buy a lot of physical and I'm having to trim back. If the art isn't interesting or the story isn't at least personally meaningful, I don't have space for it. Superb stories with boring art are a rarity anyway.
Xavier Jenkins
Tokyo Ghoul had good art from the start.
Owen Cox
ugly character design and paneling that doesn't flow
anything with too much text I drop
Cameron Fisher
This bad.
Jeremiah King
In a way this relates to the OP pic. Isayama still has chicken scratch moments, but even when he first started out with chapter 1 when everything looked like shit, the paneling and layout of the series was superb.
Kayden Mitchell
YeagerxJager
Elijah Morris
based and ishidapilled
Levi Murphy
The art style being "bad" (as in; to carttony, sketchy...) is not a problem, as long as it suits the manga, on the other hand, thing like boring or static paneling, movement that don't feel dynamic when they should, faces that don't express a lot of emotions whe needed... Can be really annoying
Jackson Williams
Is it just me or does it seem that in the past 150 chapters or so, the art of one piece just makes it incredibly difficult to read compared to what is used to be. Should I just wait for the color scene before I continue reading?
Landon Roberts
You just needed a few words to express what I tried to say in a long text. Thank you.
Asher Cox
If I pick up the manga, art work alone won't make me drop it.
It's usually asspulls and extended hiatus that make me drop that shit
Connor Campbell
Honestly, AoT has amazing facial expressions. There's a lot of snapshots of just eyes with no dialogue, and they convey so much emotion by themselves.
Oliver Martinez
I've yet to drop anything because of art. I got close with some one shot collections that had really messy art. I also dropped Liar Game, though not exclusively because of the art, but, while it wasn't really bad it just felt really stiff.
Carter Scott
Yes, the art downgrades continuously until it become really messy, with no white space, every panel full to the brim. The same happens with the story by the way, really bloated, with 1000 side characters nobody cares about, every arc is about 100 chapters long. Messy all around.