Is Naotoshi Shida a good animator?

Is Naotoshi Shida a good animator?

Attached: shiida.webm (854x480, 2.22M)

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/RMqH2dumaOU
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

Nobody needs this tryhard animation. Just animate it in a respectable way, accurate to the manga.

These are some of the ugliest designs I've ever seen . Is it One Piss?

He animates people like they're ragdolls and it constantly looks terrible despite how fluid it is.

HxH has uglier designs

Did this dude work on that IWILLNOT LET YOU DESTROY MY WORLD! Scene in battle of gods? That looked like shit,too

it's animated fine, but these designs are abhorrent

the characters look like One piece but no clue where this is from. One of the movies maybe

>accurate to the manga
So still images then?

Animation is great, but wasted on the design.
It like making the Wolrd best shitcake.
It might be excellent, but it's still a cake made with shit.

Unironically kino

Attached: goku vs hearts.webm (854x480, 2.49M)

Attached: 1554519032983.webm (852x480, 2.92M)

I only hate how the mouths keep moving

End your life, that was the only good segment.

Holy shit that looks retarded. Why does this guy with huge arms have such tiny legs? Why is everyones body parts all jiggly? It's so dumb it hurts.

>all of the fags filtered by goofy minor character designs
Get over yourselves. They're hilarious and entertaining. His animation is nice but I agree with . The movements don't make much sense at all.

Attached: 1580756733961.png (572x960, 841.59K)

>They're hilarious and entertaining.
Maybe if you are underage

and this is why you arent a successful animator

Yeppers. He was one of the GOATs until better guest talent got on the show.

Hes good though his overexxagerationnof some movements can get too crazy. The heroes one is a good one and when he did black vs goku

Dressrosa arc.
Doflamingo's crew is a bunch of hasbeens.

He over animates the hell out of his Sakuga moments. Everything just has to wobble around like hello for no reason, and he can't just have some solid, straightforward dynamic movement. Honestly, it weakens the movement in those scenes.

his style only looks good in dbz/dbs

Looks like shit.

no his constant zooming and the characters spinning all the time is annoying

youtu.be/RMqH2dumaOU

does Zig Forums watch sakuga MADs?

I hate anything he has done for One Piece. I don't watch the anime, but whenever I check a clip I can instantly recognize his animation and it always looks bad

He makes Luffy, who is made of fucking rubber, look too rubbery.

Holy shit Wan Piss is ugly KEK.

Attached: kek.png (869x680, 314.85K)

He undoubtedly has mad skills and experience in animation, but he overdoes his camera rotations and exagerates the character movements too much for my taste (the famous wobbly heads).
I prefer Ryo Onishi, his cut in the Broly movie was the most impressive of them all.

He's terrible

Other guy is right, being a tryhard is really distracting and unartistic.

what're they doing with their mouths
that looks so unnatural and weird

Quality aside, stylistically it just looks awful (not talking about the character designs, though those are awful too).