Why is such an unbelievably bad show so highly rated?

Why is such an unbelievably bad show so highly rated?

Attached: 115489.jpg (700x437, 49.17K)

Muh feels.

I was going to make a similar thread with "what went wrong" instead in a few minutes, guess I don't need to now.

This was good.

Are you just one of those that got pissed off at the ending?

This
but also this

The one thing I couldn't stand about this was the absolute cringe from when the MC was crying to himself in his inner thoughts. Maybe its because I watched it dubbed and the english voice actor sucked, but it was just terrible

>I watched it dubbed

Attached: 1472220129583.png (544x499, 209.81K)

It was one of the first anime I watched before I learned better. It was a dark time

Am I the only one that was pissed off with how much of the music got silenced by the faggy MC having the same inner monologue several times? I wanted to listen to the music, not his muted notes and fucking rambling.

That's what I was talking about here

This might be the worst anime I've ever watched in my entire life, god this was so fucking bad.
>OH NO MY NOTES I CAN'T HEAR THEM AGAIN
yeah shit was annoying

this show was fucking terrible, the plot was predictable from the very start. The only redeeming point was the final performance because the music was actually good and they were allowed to play for longer than ten seconds.

Like, it felt like I had to sit through that shit way more times than was necessary. It felt padded out. Also, the girls' death was so heavily flagged that it meant nothing when it arrived. Part of death's tragedy, and the impact of it in fiction is either its tragic suddenness, or the way it drags out and sucks the life out of you knowing it's inevitably coming. With her, it was foreshadowed, and then just sort of happened, so you got neither.

It's not a masterpiece but definitely not a bad anime. It's also has nice op and ed songs.

she was also an annoying and frustrating character which made it hard to care about her death at all desu.

Am I going to get better?
Oh look a special surgery
No I died even faster

Kinda annoying desu, makes rewatching it unappealing

No it wasn't good and yes it was objectively terrible.

It made me want a girlfriend and then kill myself
GOOD Opening thO

>good opening
wrong.jpg

>the plot was predictable from the very start
This. I knew this blonde girl will die in the same moment i saw her because how genki and "full of life" she was. Also this whole idea of how mc just randomly lost his musical talent is terrible. Haven't watch past first episode tho.

First OP was great and you're a fag for thinking otherwise.

A show doesn't need to surprise you to be good. The show didn't pretend like Kaori's death was unexpected.

MC being emotional isn't a bad thing. I don't know why I'm responding to this since you're probably baiting by mentioning the dub.

If this show was one cour or maybe even a movie, it would have been much less tedious.

I mean, you could tell from the synopsis that was going to happen. It's literal oscarbait and it's obvious why. It "tackles" serious issues, even if it's done poorly, so people have no idea how to criticize it or are too scared to criticize it because of how important those issues are. It doesn't matter how bad or how introductory it is as far as those topics are.

because it was good

I couldn't stand the godawful "comedy". It ruined the whole show. Everytime I would start to get invested in the plot and characters it would do some dumbass slapstick bullshit and throw me right out of the show.

>Kimiuso
The very definition of trite.

Normalfaggotry at its finest. Artificial drama, forced comedy and no direction as to what emotion it wants to be. If you want sad shit that is good, I'd rather go to another medium (i,e Manchester by the Sea)

I like the OP. But God damn, everyone's praising this like the Second coming. As well as SukaSuka.

Attached: K9__01.png (1066x646, 381.37K)

This is a fucking anime. Of course the characters will talk. You can still listen to music as everything is all shit that exists. Mostly Chopin.

kek

Normies first "Sad" anime. "Look mom she is sick, ohnoez she died. Life is so fragile. such a deep cartoon" basicly.
Dont get me wrong, it was good, but very very overrated. Also hands were animated very nicely.