Why does this anime get praised so much? It's 8/10 at most

Why does this anime get praised so much? It's 8/10 at most.

Attached: jpeg the anime.jpg (474x266, 23.43K)

>8/10 at most
Yes and that makes it one of the best anime ever made.

Attached: 1573407564844.jpg (1920x1080, 236.1K)

It doesn't get the amount of attention it deserves, how the fuck is madoka overrated in any way? How often do you see normalfags mentioning it or showing love for it? Never.

Attached: 1601093347652.jpg (1056x720, 127.94K)

ClariS desu

Zig Forums and teh leddits are full of madokafags

Same reason FMA gets praised so much.
Being less bad than others of the “genre” will do that for you.

If this series had the exact same plot but Puellæ Magi were replaced by Flame Hazes and instead of frilly dresses they wore black trenchcoats it wouldn't be lauded so much and would be yet another grimdark battle series which has some interesting moral relativity going on, which is what it is.

But now it's a grimdark MAGICAL GIRL battle series with interesting moral relativity going on — 10/10 kino.

8/10 is a high score.

>going to reddit
kys you'reself

Specifically to make you angry

Does overrated mean Zig Forums majority opinion in your point if view? Huh

for it's a 10/10 the only mahosojo I liked beside madoka is minky momo

>does overrated mean overrated to you
yes

It's a good anime that transformed the genre forever

it doesn't?
last I checked the data doesn't indicate a ton of praise

Don't be ridiculous

>is just magic little girls dying
>interesting grimdark moral relativity deconstruction
care to eggsblain?

I didn't think it was a masterpiece at first
but then Rebellion came out

Where did you even do that? Do it again.

>it's only liked because it's mahou shoujo
I'm not much of a fan of the genre but I can recognize Madoka is a very well executed series.

The entire thing with Kyubey and stuff and how he justifies his using of humans moral relativity.
Dying is grimdark.

It's not a bad series, but let's not act like grimdark moral relativity is a super groundbreaking thing, it simply is in M.G. as a genre.

major anime sites

The pivotal episode 10 aired on the same day as the 2011 earthquake and tsunami.

Attached: Madoka 10.jpg (3688x2330, 2.54M)

Posts like these used to be considered blatant shitposting, can't believe someone tell for them kek

>Googol seerch rezult noomber wang
>Oupen MaL
>See Madka mugic
>Rank 157
oki

never forget

Attached: 1422409241524.jpg (2339x1956, 1.16M)

>It's 8/10
So you admit it's better than most anime?

it's not even in the top 150
in what world is that "praised so much"

Attached: 1573883699987.png (1434x1050, 1.64M)

Not in the west, but surely in Japan

>It's 8/10 at most.
Its 11/10 at worst.

Madoka is among the greatest shows of its decade, at the minimum.