Madoka Magika is 90% shock effect . Take that out and you are left with a messy story full of conveniences
It means nothing next to Sailor Moon for me; the very same show most think it’s boring and too long. Heck, it is the exact same story. It has magic conveniences there too but the end result comes after a long duration of fleshing out its characters. After 200 episodes of mostly silly battles and slice-of-life moments, I loved the cast and the story and the whole messages it offers to the viewer. Heck, I even loved the villains. Do we know anything about who the Witches were in Madoka? They are faceless mooks. Or are we supposed to care about Mami, a girl we barely know of just because she got killed in a few episodes?
It is also a show without characters. I am not joking; there are no characters in this anime. There are only dolls without free will. They have no control over their actions and everything moves fatalistically and without them being able to change it. Until we get a cop-out ending that trashes everything of course. How do people even liked these robots of characters? Sayaka is the only one who is delved upon and only because they offered a quarter of the show on her. The others are just stereotypes with vague traits and unsupported claims.
it's not bait just because you don't agree explain how op is wrong
Jeremiah Watson
>madokafags cant read who would have known hahahahahaha
Dominic Perry
ok
Alexander Hill
I would never watch this trash it looks like a baby show for gay little girls. I only watch 100% heterosexual anime like jojo.
Levi Adams
I like Madoka but I do think it could have used more episodes like you're saying. But that doesn't fit with the current industry or with the people that watch seasonal anime that have gotten used to 13 episode seasons. I still haven't watched/read Sailor Moon either. I need to get on that.
Kayden Gray
Based and true, madokafags are pathetic and delusional.
Madoka is the crown jewel of fiction. All criticism brought forth in this thread does not even address it. One has to meet a standard in order to talk about it. You did not understand. You can not understand. And you will never understand even the first thing about it. Even when the day comes when Madoka will be the state religion of the empire that shall rise from the ashes of this word - even then, you will understand nothing about it. But thank Madoka, the kind of blasphemy as you are committing here will be punishable by death. Look forward to it!
David Perez
Moron.
Carson Morgan
Madoka Magika is 90% shock effect . Take that out and you are left with a messy story full of conveniences
It means nothing next to Sailor Moon for me; the very same show most think it’s boring and too long. Heck, it is the exact same story. It has magic conveniences there too but the end result comes after a long duration of fleshing out its characters. After 200 episodes of mostly silly battles and slice-of-life moments, I loved the cast and the story and the whole messages it offers to the viewer. Heck, I even loved the villains. Do we know anything about who the Witches were in Madoka? They are faceless mooks. Or are we supposed to care about Mami, a girl we barely know of just because she got killed in a few episodes?
It is also a show without characters. I am not joking; there are no characters in this anime. There are only dolls without free will. They have no control over their actions and everything moves fatalistically and without them being able to change it. Until we get a cop-out ending that trashes everything of course. How do people even liked these robots of characters? Sayaka is the only one who is delved upon and only because they offered a quarter of the show on her. The others are just stereotypes with vague traits and unsupported claims
Colton Reyes
Let me guess, you're the schizo who keeps repeating "y-you didnt watch it then!!" each time madoka is met with criticism?
Jeremiah Gonzalez
He can't, and if he did Madoka would still be better.
Oliver Morris
Madoki magical is a masterpiece you heretic
Luis Brown
>Sayaka is the only one who is delved upon and only because they offered a quarter of the show on her. I agree...
Nathan Collins
at least it had a story/plot unlike the fluffy romcoms that come out nowadays
Blake Campbell
Based
Joseph White
No. I am not that person (though he is quite based and not wrong actually as you SHOULD actually watch it). It is said: Though Madoka is ever true, a proof of gods existence and his last message to his creation, some people watch Madoka: and they understand the bare bones of it. And if I were to spend an entire thread explaining to them a mundane detail of the whole ordeal, they would end up getting it and be content with it, and go home having learned something. But the whole picture forever eludes them and an eternity would hardly suffice to explain everything to them. Other people however, watch Madoka, and it is as if they have never watched it at all. They might have as well been asleep during this - or as I come to conclude they are when awake as they are in their sleep.
You see he is not wrong in that you didn‘t watch it. As the effect is not measurable. You might have or you might have not. For your kind it hardly makes a difference. It’s like asking a deaf man if he listened to a song. What difference does it make? Or like asking a dog how if he looked at a pretty picture.
What is written here is not even addressing Madoka. It’s literally an equivalent to „lol they are putting toilet water on the fields!!!“ from idiocracy. I know that we are putting water on the fields, retard. The fact that you think that it’s a good idea to water plants with energy drinks just speaks for itself
Jace Taylor
Don't bother. It's shoujoshit.
Asher Nguyen
This
Lucas Hughes
I've liked a lot of other shoujo manga so I doubt that will cause any issue. And the anime is apparently made less shoujo-y like a lot of other shoujo anime adaptations like CCS.
Nicholas Davis
madaka magico is the most OP shonen protagonist since deku
