Why did it go to shit after season 1? Was it the melodrama?

Why did it go to shit after season 1? Was it the melodrama?

Attached: 81ttkOl00ZL._RI_.jpg (1600x1200, 384.75K)

It became what it was parodying so I dropped it. I don't regret it.

watari wanted to be a DEEP writer, but he also wanted his self-insert to have the happy ending he couldn't get irl

I haven't watched this but Yui just looks far superior. She looks like a real cutie and makes me wanna watch the show

>Animefags complain about development on a mostly 1rst person perspective LN
>they miss the useless thoughts, the ideas and the complains of the MC in the first place by not reading the LN
>They complain that volume 6 forwards is a different story when in the very first volume they already speak about genuine and how flawed 8man is.
Why am i supposed to hear you? you won't even give it any proper attention anyway.

Attached: 1605523844968.png (800x729, 165.29K)

So season 1 was only good on accident? Huh what shame

>implying S1 was good when they skipped entire parts with Zaimokuza and Totsuka
>implying S1 was good when it skipped the gaming club part.
Nah, the anime was below average on quality compared to the LN, which is amazing but it was worth it seeing animated.

Attached: 1589099275518.jpg (611x548, 69.12K)

Almost. The source material is garbage, and season 1 was elevated by Ai Yoshimura's directing. But the best thing she's ever done is still the second part of Gintama episode 111.

FPBP

Actually good series are good regardless of the media. Haruhi and Monogatari are entertaining because the MCs are charismatic, they are played by great seiyuu, and they are directed in a way that doesn't suppress the first person narrating (not to mention having a story that is more than teenagers lusting over each other like the majority of LNs).

This, anime only babbies make no sense.

Its only gimmick about it was the protagonist being like a random incel in reality dropped into a romcom. He became less edgy after S1 and it became just another romcom with lots of dull and pretentious dialogue.

I watched the first season when it came out, I was a teen back then and I liked the edginess.
Now as a mature upstanding adult citizen I think it's shit.

>What was her problem?
>She's too beautiful!

Attached: yukinoSHITa.png (1280x720, 669.13K)

This. Sourcefags are retarded. Only the anime matters when judging the anime. Only total losers care about the LN trash.

ENTER

Attached: yugami 5.jpg (860x1400, 264.61K)

Monogatari is trash. Don't you dare put it on the same level as Haruhi.

Yet here you are on a board for losers.

This is the anime board for people still semi-normal. Go to /jp/, pathetic scum.

Semi-normal people don't watch anime and engage in best girl discussions.

>endless shit
yea no, kyoani at their peak cant fuck with shaft at their peak

Attached: Mayoi.gif (232x500, 551.21K)

Just rewatched all of it and S1 is probably the the worst season desu. Tied right there with S3, 8man is not the person you think he is.

>8man is not the person you think he is.
I think this why some loud minority on this board hate anything past S1.

It was actually okay in the beginning to middle parts of S2, but jesus that ending.

Going for the 12th rewatch of Disappearance this year and while it's a masterpiece, Monogatari as a whole is fantastic experience. Haruhi has aged for sure and even if it still holds up, Monogatari's quality has been great through all its adaptations.

Season 1 did a shit job at depicting 8man and Yukino's character development. Season 2 ends up looking a lot worse to anime onlies who haven't read the LNs and don't understand what's going on.

>Kyon is charismatic
Araragi i'll give you that one,he's flawed too(because he's an absolute moron).
also
>thinking that Haruhi is good.

Attached: 1605007489618.jpg (458x545, 53K)

Art style change.

Monogatari, Haruhi and Oregairu are all shit.
Bunnygirl Senpai is the best with Saekano being a close second

Attached: 1602702355656.jpg (2048x1394, 382.94K)

Attached: 3aed919b1b5a725ace1a8c50bbb6ba63.jpg (720x1081, 71.68K)

>Senjougahara not in that pile of trash image
Based user BTFO itself

>they are autistic so this is really romantic!
Kek

Name a single anime that can beat any of the KeyAni anime.
You can't.

Based. Fuck Feel and their rampant Yukinofaggotry.

Attached: 1596730887741.jpg (1500x960, 424.27K)

Sore losers 1 year and counting.