Justify Why I Should Give This a 10

Do it

Attached: madoka_magica_rebellion_poster2.jpg (550x550, 176.58K)

It angers plotlets

What justifies a 10/0 anyway? Nothing can be perfect.
I guess if you enjoy every moment it's 10/10?

If you're asking for justification, then don't.

It's a 7/10

It's good. It continues Homura's character arc that was left unfinished in the show (Oh, you're going to sacrifice yourself again, Madoka? Okay, that's fine). And it has great visuals. Some of Shaft's best imo.

Attached: MadokaHomuraSuicide.gif (500x281, 1019.35K)

You should give it a 5

>assigning numerical value to entertainment

10/10 is when it is better than 90% of existing anime. So out of thousands of titles hundreds will be 10/10.

Holy shit, that's a bad take.

I appreciate trying to be objective, but imagine how many mediocre anime would end up 10/10 just because there's so much dogshit anime

I didn't give it a 10 myself, but it is still a really good movie.

It varies between 5/10 and 8/10 on everyone’s first watch, but it becomes a 10/10 on a second watch, also for everyone.

It's the best mahou shoujo.

nice timestamp

The visuals were pretty good, the OST was killer, the girls are cute, QB got fucked, Sayaka got fucked, more Homura, more Madoka, more of the rest of the magical girls, cute Nagissa, Devil Homura was cool ending...That's all I got.

At the very least it was better than that shitty Stein's ;Fag movie.

I don't have to justify anything. If you don't see it you got filtered and are also a pleb unworthy of our Madokami grace.
Perish, vermin

Attached: Ultimate.Madoka.full.1975926.jpg (1150x793, 1013.53K)

Cause it's like everyone's favorite movie Inception, except it makes sense.

This.

Based and true god pilled

You don't.

Rebellion is trash.
The series is 10/10

Attached: __kaname_madoka_and_ultimate_madoka_mahou_shoujo_madoka_magica_drawn_by_taniguchi_jun_ichirou__e482a9381b3574b236e95ddf6a61610b.jpg (1000x1000, 210.18K)

When it is clearly at or near the apex of the medium by some combination of great execution and innovation. Taking 10/10 to be perfect means you never get to use the top of the scale so it's retarded.

Shit taste. Rebellion is great.

>he doesn't rate Rebellion
Heh, tell me how does it feel having a sub 100 IQ?

Now this is a high IQ post.

Low IQ post.

Now the dust has settled did Homura actually do anything wrong?

Rebellion is otaku-pandering fanfic-tier moneygrab.
It has zero artistic value and only exists to suck wallets of otaku.

Attached: madoka rebellion.png (1172x1738, 379.66K)

The entire problem with it is the subpar plot at times.
The æsthetic and sound design is amazing but the plot has problems.

Any plot that has an “any one wish” mechanic is bound to have problems.

Attached: trollface.png (800x572, 200.46K)

you shouldn't, no anime is a 10/10, especially not muhdoka

It had forced surrealism and sacrificed its characters like cattle.
definitely an 8/10 at best