ITT terrible endings

>whole manga leads up to this fight
>gennosuke wins but is mentally fucked and loses his mie
what the fuck was the point of any of this? the story was dragging on, the final fight took many chapters to start and the action didnt last long. honestly besides the art i dont see what else is good shigurui is a fucking mess story wise.

Attached: Shigurui - v15-AnonymousStem- - 200.png (1280x1851, 888.14K)

2DEEP4U

People are going to call you a pleb but I honestly agree. 70-80% of Shigurui's actual story was done by volume like 6 or so, the manga was way longer than it needed to be.

>shigurui is a fucking mess story wise.


it's a multiple volume fan fiction of a fight the creator read in a book as a kid and wanted to learn more about, so he made shit up.


Tranny and frog guy where apparently also characters in the book.

You just didn't get it

what is there to get?

The ending is really good because its painful.

>Gennosuke wins
>But now must choose between honorable death or a dishonorable life
>Despite it all, Gennosuke is true samurai, he will follow an order
>This breaks Mie's heart because he hasn't and will never change, their being together is duty for him
>Yet Gennosuke does feel the weight of his action, hesitating before decapitation

He lost everything. Pretty neatly wraps things up.

Attached: v23.png (1280x1859, 1.02M)

>filtered by chinese cartoon yet again

I get that its painful and he struggled hard just to have everything he worked for fall flat in his face. It's just not executed correctly because this entire time gennosuke has been losing. He jobs against strong opponents the whole manga but wins against no names. The only fights that actually mattered he ends up losing. I dont get how thats good.

>doesnt know what filtered means

at least I know what the ending means

Feudalism and Samurai's are fetishized in culture while everything was actually fucked in reality.

Also I believe it is an adaption of a larger story where the two main character's in Shigurui are just side characters if I'm not mistaken.

>he thinks not liking the ending means i dont get it

Attached: Shigurui - v14-AnonymousStem- - 157.png (950x1400, 695.36K)

Never read a tragedy before?

>the start of the story makes it seems like story will focus on seigan and gennosuke
>jumps around from character to character for world building purposes
this is the shit that makes the story fall short for me. worldbuilding and introducing characters is nice but damn near every chapter there was a new face and its getting tedious to keep up with so many names/people. its not hard just annoying to have an overloaded cast but the entire story is ONLY about two people.

if you really did you would like it because it's damn good. But I guess not everyone can have good taste.

The worst ending of all time ever is Negima.

she told him she loved hm because he told her he renounced being a samurai and would live to fight and die.

he wins that match and then gets told by the lord to make sure his opponent's dead by beheading to have the honor of a samurai. he freezes and realizes he does in fact want to be a samurai, is giddy he'll have his honor restored and she realizes she threw her life away following him for nothing.

I think in the book he dies from his wounds a short time later. The other irony is in the book Shigurui was based on their fight was like a footnote in the beginning chapters as people enjoyed watching the cripples fight.

>honestly besides the art i dont see what else is good shigurui is a fucking mess story wise.
Do yourself a favor and read books instead of manga. If you don't get the appeal of even Shigurui then you are simply reading the wrong medium.

the only tragedy ending manga or anime i can remember is angel beats and i barely remember that. i need to read more but im in the middle of usogui right now so i want to finish that. im just not really sold on the landing of shigurui. build up to the tournament fight was good but the fight itself was 2 chapters? not that eventful and irako vs kogan had better art and was more intense. majority of the good moments in this manga came from irako and gennosuke felt more like a side character. gennosuke doesnt feel like a main character until the end of the manga when he starts to be the main focus. its just an average story with god tier art.

Attached: Shigurui - v14-AnonymousStem- - 97.png (950x1400, 745.5K)

Found it. Kaina - Surugajou Gozen-Jiai is the manga adaption of Surugajou Gozen-Jiai which features a one arm warrior and cripple warrior which Shigurui is based on.

>its just an average story
So average that people can't forget it

>people like a thing i dont like
thats fine? i dont know what that has to do with what i said,

It really isn't an enjoyable manga, but I'm glad I read it if it makes sense. I was really disappointed too when I finished it. But it's one of those things you look back on and kind of appreciate the more you think about it,

It's pretty simple. Gennosuke was able to get rid of the ghost that was haunting him by defeating Seigen. Seigen is free and to some degree, he is happy Fujiki ended his suffering, Lady Iku also commits suicide to escape the pain and suffering, similar to Irako.
The problem comes after Tokugawa orders Fujiki to cut the head of Irako, Gennosuke doesn't want to disrespect his rival (and even friend), he transforms into a slave again. For Mie, Gennosuke is now forever tainted, another slave that will do what he is ordered, she decides to end her life, Fujiki ends completely alone and destroyed emotionally.

>It really isn't an enjoyable manga, but I'm glad I read it if it makes sense.
Same. I may not have enjoyed the ending but the ride itself wasn't that bad and the characters were grounded enough to relate to their morals. I really enjoyed everything besides the last 2 volumes. It just didnt end how i thought it would.

Liar Game, such a letdown

Attached: whatsthis.png (921x592, 359.21K)

filtered

>liked majority of the manga
>filtered
go back to your shonen general if you arent going to actually discuss anything nigger

Sun Ken Rock's is notoriously bad, although its still worth reading despite the ending.

shonen these balls on your chin cunt

dilate tranny nigger nobody thinks your smart or cool

Attached: w7cchCu.png (592x512, 300.57K)

I wish Zig Forums was shut down. This site would become much better without those underage retards.

>SKR
i just got through the idol arc and that shit was fucking terrible. you're telling me it gets WORSE?

haha nice faggot reaction image bitch mind if I save?