Game has bad worldbuilding

Isn't it just the typical feudal system? Why we would need to explain that in a book?

Based 7d chess autist

>game has a god of evil
>curbstomped by a bigger god of evil
I can only think of one game.

Attached: 1578956243515.png (869x601, 465.96K)

t. Brainlet you never read anything involving the first and second age. Christ you illiterate retards should kill yourselves

It isn't, but that's not what he is saying.

KOTOR2 fags still getting filtered by the Tolkster

>everthing is black and white
have you read lotr at all

Tolkien wrote mythologies. Martin writes soft erotica for horny women when it was popular during the 50 Shades of Grey era.

I've read three GoT books and they sucked.

Reminder Tolkien actually did write about this kind of shit and he had a whole bunch of appendices explaining shit like how his medievalish Europe had tobacco despite America not being discovered yet.

What's Elden Ring's tax policy?

That's not even the worst of Martin's ramble on Tolkien.
He even fervently argues that Tolkien made a mistake in bringing Gandalf back.

Attached: George RR Martin.png (1552x750, 496.23K)

Most of it is not worth reading unless you surround yourself with all of Tolkien's writings. It's very dry like Children of Hurin, but he definitely made a new mythology with it.

You could not even imagine it

Wow that quote is... perfectly reasonable. And the "critics" of it have to deliberate distort/cherrypick it, really says it all.

How come so many shit authors rip Tolkien off to squeeze out their turd stories but are still so far behind his logical layouts and structure

Yes user we think it's very cool that you are contrarian

Not autistic enough.

He's saying "I loved it so much I wanted more but it never came", nothing wrong with that.

>He even fervently argues that Tolkien made a mistake in bringing Gandalf back.
And he is right.

Tolkien wasn't exactly a God-like author. He was alright, but I think you're overselling him.

>No prease undastandu Missa Yorge RR Mahtin, dis is a wideogame not a mirrion page nowel book. We need to sink of de prayers and da gaempuray.
>"Listen, *huff* do you want the Game of Thrones quality or not? *sweat-farts* You're the ones who wanted me because you liked my award winning *rips into bag of chips* HBO series. We need TAX-- *punches chest to restart heart* TAXES! We need taxes and lots of rape and interracial. Gotta put Global Warming in there, too, and hamfisted political interplay--speaking of ham, where's my ninth sammich?
>PREASE UNDASTANDU MISSA MAHTIN! DIS WIDEOGAME NOT A--
>You will either have the character's dicks with stat sheet measurements or you won't have my contribution at all!

>50 shades comes out early 2010's almost all at once
>asoiaf came out more than ten years earlier and has been worked on for nearly 20
Wow that's an apt comparison you tranny

you're not funny

hello /sffg/!

>everything is black and white

Attached: 1511442680_23754682_10215305588212430_1380445212684780064_n.jpg (419x610, 38.66K)

lmao

Attached: 1589213979369.jpg (1200x993, 229.95K)

I rather read that fanfiction than that other fanfiction with hilarious mild "bdsm"

Can't believe how many sycophantic and/or willfully ignorant posters there are defending this horse's ass.

>perfectly reasonable
>completely missing the theme, spirit and tone of the work
>wanting unnecessary narrative additions to keep the story going and/or bloat the conclusion
>bringing up utter minutia no one else cares about
>"Orcs and Elves intermarry?"

>reasonable

>He's saying
No look at what he actually said, not what you wanted him to say.

You're retarded.

>overselling Tolkien
You have to be 18yrs or older to post here.

Attached: 1582398910948.png (1022x1274, 1.19M)

The real joke about The Silmarillion is that Tolkien was afraid it won't be well received because of no hobbit protag.