>When they were first making Persona 4, the developers intended for either Nanako or Yukiko to be the killer instead of Adachi
>They changed it instead of using Nanako because it would've been too dark and thought gamers would've hated this twist
>They changed it instead of using Yukiko because they thought it would be too heavy and emotional for the gamer.
Were they right for this change, Zig Forums?
>They changed it instead of using Yukiko because they thought it would be too heavy and emotional for the gamer
It would've been the first time Yukiko evoked any amount of emotion in anyone though.
yeah nanako being the killer would be just... too dark for gamers...
sounds kino
sounds stupid
It wasn't Nanako it was Dojima.
Women are incapable of murder or evil so I understand the change.
Wasn't it actually supposed to be Dojima in the original?
Imagine actually believing persona 4 has girls that are better than sumire!!! AHAHAHAHA LOSERS!!!
The Yukiko twist would've been cool.
Nanako is also Dojima.
Atlas always has these great ideas and instead ship out something lame instead.
Like for P5 I heard originally you were supposed to live with Makoto and Sae, but they changed that.
>they intended the killer to be a goddamn toddler
cool story bro
The first draft was that Nanako was mind controlling Dojima, and that his entire existence was just an elaborate fabrication.
Hashino is a pussy who bends to the desires of Persona's perceived demographics.
Honestly kino
u wot
Nanako wouldn't work because she's a tiny motherfucker and Personas don't work in the real world. That being said, Yukiko could've been interesting if her relationship with the protagonist influenced things.
Sort of reminds me of Maruki
That sounds fucking cool not gonna lie
Would've been kino
>Personas don't work in the real world
Didn't they retcon this? Wasn't Maruki technically using his persona in the real world and altering reality?
I swear to god I've heard like 4 different characters were intended to be the villain instead of Adachi. I hope Atlus just comes out one day and says who they intended to be at first.
>Personas don't work in the real world
Yes they do lol
If it were an SMT situation where IRL Japan is fucked, then these Persona kids would be able to use their Personas and negotiate with Demons.
>it would be too heavy and emotional for the gamer.
holy shit that korean roasting of japan not knowing concepts like love was true all along
Maruki's Persona was so powerful it was practically a God. But yeah Personas can be used in the real world. Maruki used his by accident though.
Didn’t they work in persona 3 atleast? You use a evoker to kill ryoji before the dark hour.
Post it
Maruki's worked in the real world but iirc they hand waved the issue away by saying it was because he had an extremely extremely powerful Persona or something like that. I think Atlus kind of flip flops on it but usually leans towards no.
I wouldn't know. I never got around to 5 so I'm not going to pretend I know in that field.
Demons showing up changes the rules. That's not just Nocturne. Demons materializing IRL fundamentally changes the laws of physics.
Yukiko is the best girl though
>I never got around to 5 so I'm not going to pretend I know in that field.
Wow, you don't see that often.
Personas not working in the real world has always been my biggest gripe with the recent games. Takes away so many plot angles.
