Bioshock Thread

Which one was your favorite?
What should the next one be like? Where should it take place?

Also sorry, I've already claimed Elizabeth.

Attached: bioshock logo.jpg (400x400, 37.37K)

I like infinite because it doesn’t end with you raising a bunch of coal burners. 2 is for faggots. It doesn’t need another game, Gore Verbinski needs to do the movie

1 is obviously the best. 2 was a trash heap and infinite was good but had a storyline that was just okay.

Bioshock 2 + minerva's den
Like a real bioshock and not like infinite
Could still take place in columbia since the aesthetic was the one good thing, but maybe it would be cooler in a new underground city.

>Could still take place in columbia since the aesthetic was the one good thing, but maybe it would be cooler in a new underground city.
this. We could have Bioshock 4 take place in post-comstock columbia, maybe the 30's-40's to perhaps utilize some WW2 type shenanigans, but also return to form with the gameplay of Bioshock 1 and 2. Also have actual replacements for big daddies this time around, since songbird was pretty much only delegated to cutscenes. Hell, just take all of songbird's concept art designs and size them down and you have the PERFECT columbia-styled big daddy replacements.

Attached: songbird concept art 1.jpg (1280x938, 270.94K)

>Which one was your favorite?
Infinite

I unironically love them all. I don't fault anyone for hating infinite though, it's quite a departure from the first two games.

1 is the best didn’t even remember what happened in 2. Infinite was alright.

might as well post all of the concept art for Songbird

Attached: songbird concept art 2.jpg (500x667, 87.59K)

Attached: songbird concept art 3.jpg (1764x2369, 549.86K)

and that's all I've got. seriously though, these would make fore awesome big daddies.

Attached: songbird concept art 4.jpg (2448x3264, 734.14K)

Bump

2>1>horseshit>inf

The reddit opinion

2 is objectively the strongest game in the series mechanically.

It's almost as though you're a trolling retard.

Bioshock 2 is shit, did you people not watch Zero Punctuation?

Literally who?

>What should the next one be like? Where should it take place?

I've got a few.
A retrofuture city on the moon, the ambitious future of the 50s realized just to crumble again. A brutalist city deep inside the jungle with the vegetation reclaiming the concrete. A neoclassicistic city resting atop the Himalayas with parts of it build into the mountains. An industrial metropolis build underground, factories and brick, a city made out of iron that never saw the sunlight.
Don't know about the ideologies that each one represents, but that's the least important aspect in my opinion. What made Bioshock stand out among other fps was always the setting, not the gameplay and definitely not the story.

3rd one should be detective story in the earth's core

All kino environments. You could just make up ideologies as you went along for these. Alternatively, there is still a lot left do be done with Columbia.

the next one should be in the antartic

2 > Inf > 1
I can never be bothered to reply 1. Gameplay is a shit version of 2 with the last two levels being dogshit, confronting Ryan is the only good part of the story and Atlus gives you lore and shit for literally no reason. At least Infinite had the twist actually recontextualise dialogue.

1 is just too fkn long

Why?

>Gameplay is a shit version of 2 with the last two levels being dogshit
This. The hacking puzzles and big daddy mission ruined the game

1. 2 had better gameplay but I liked the environments and story (except for the stuff after Ryan's death) of 1 more. Both are great. There shouldn't be another one.

Can’t believe people actually think 2 is better. It’s so poor compared to 1.

It’s the dark souls shit all over again.

What’s wrong with 2?

bioshock 1 story and setting + bioshock 2 gameplay and mechanics would be my ideal. the linearity of 2 sucks but 1's gameplay is so clunky it's hard to replay

Infinite is dogshit and minerva's den was the end of bioshock

I can smell the sóylent on your breath

Is this a joke?

if you want to keep the thread alive, atleast use better bait

When I played Bioshock 1 and saw that they couldn't even do basic fucking FPS mechanics right, I gave up on the entire franchise and never cared afterwards.
Fuck that stupid series.

2 is literally poor fanservice for people that liked 1 what are you on about