Soulless vs Soul

Soulless vs Soul

Attached: 1582889156305.jpg (480x360, 42.19K)

Kinda but no, p4 and 3 was mostly just reused assets the game but P5 was made entirely from scratch.

Kinda this, P4 and P3 dungeons were shit and P5 vastly improved on them. That said, P5 had the worst cast out of the three and Joker could never come close to matching the alpha status of Chad Ziodynecock.

Attached: 1581538046009.png (655x859, 24.53K)

>t. animeonly

P4 is one of the most soulful games ever made. The weather effects, the NPCs feeling like they have an actual life and places to go, the comparatively good cast for a video game of this kind, the extreme thematic consistency between most of the games events, "Persona" and the social links, etc.

It was but apart from some nice style the story and characters just felt a bit hollow to me

Will P5 become soulful once it's on PC?

Either if it comes to PC, switch, or if P6 comes out. Then it'll be soulful while the new one will be soulless
Until then, Zig Forumstards will be Zig Forumstards

Persona 5 objectively has the most soul of all the persona games and if you disagree you’re a retarded contrarian.

this

Joker
>Is embarrassed looking at Ann's and Makoto's chest in the car
>always getting bitched on by the cat
>has to sent a calling card because he is too pussy to show his face
>only steals hearts of other men because he is too insecure with women

THE CAD
>People only know him as CHAD
>Introduces himself to the class by calling the teacher a cuck
>not even the first day over and two girls already throw herself at him
>Kuma is admiring the Chad and does what he wants
>lives in a relatives house. The owner and his daughter are living by CHAD's rules
>Pretty much all people who he "rescues" are women
>all men in his team are accepting that the girls are for the CHAD only
>he literally fucks girls that are top tier fighters, have top tier grades, or are model other people wish to be able to fuck
>has a fox as his dungeon pet because fuck you

Let's not forget

Joker
>tries to whiteknight when he sees as woman being assaulted
>destroys his life

you cant beat the chad. i find it funny the writer of persona 4 apologies to the virgins for making Ziodynecock too chad for them to relate too.

Did narukami get to bang a milf? no. In fact, he ran away from one
Joker banged a teacher, a doctor, a journalist and almost banged a prosecutor

Yes, 5 hour train rides followed by a series of increasingly disappointing tourist traps are very soulful.

Sojiro is the real chad of P5, every time the ladies see his fedora they turn as red as his curry and as wet as his coffee.

Both are soulless. Now kneel to the true soul

Attached: 4CFE9226-F638-4E3A-8DBB-5B8F5DFBACA7.jpg (600x838, 389.15K)

>teacher
LITERAL whore
>doctor
throws herself at him, not even his choice
>journalist
*vomiting noises*
>almost prosecutor
>almost
self-explanatory

>chad
>raises not only another man's daughter but another woman's daughter as well

None of them are MILFs, you fool.
Also, it's depressingly easy to fuck single women who are past their prime.

Narukami doesn't have to hide the fact that he banged everyone though, as women just throw themselves at him.
Joker is hated by most everyone at his school with exeption of the phantom thieves and teacher, and if any of them find out he was with another woman they flip the fuck out which can only be repaired by sojiro the true chad.

narukami is no ones sloby second.

I don't see 3 in there zoomer

you forgot

>scammer hike
necrophiliac? ewww...

More like soul vs oversoul.

P5 is objectively the best one and anyone who says otherwise is either a nostalgiafag or a retarded faggot.

t. only Perona game played is 5 and only after joker smash reveal

P4 is genuinely the epitome of soulless, and I say that as a near-lifelong Persona fan and a big lover of P4. It was an asset flip of P3 that completely usurped the atmosphere and darkness of previous Persona titles in favor of cutesy slice of life anime crap. It is genuinely the textbook definition of removing soul: ripping out challenging approaches to storytelling in favor of more accessible ones while neglecting to upgrade the visuals or mechanics in any way.

If you think P4 is "soul" you are a zoomer, period. You weren't here when P4 came out. Even fans of it acknowledged it for what it was, and only smooth brains are retroactively changing that opinion. It will always be an asset flip of P3 whose tone totally shifted the direction future Persona games would take, causing irreparable damage to the franchise. Great game though.

Who is best Persona girl?

Attached: 1538444095449.jpg (592x821, 67.21K)

>all men in his team are accepting that the girls are for the CHAD only
This shit's really annoying. If you get to rank 10 of a social link don't romance the girl, none of the dudes in your party have the balls to step in and make a move.
Kanji clearly has a thing for Naoto
Ryuji and Ann clearly like each other but nether one says anything
Yusuke and Futaba are practically completing each other's sentences in the group texts by the end of the game
Letting the side characters start fucking if the protag doesn't step up would make them a hell of a lot more believable. Am I really suppose to buy that two groups of 7+ horny teenagers didn't get together and try to fuck after a year of near daily hanging out? Forget it

Attached: 44bbbd9d19a4506013445ff4fc38c422.png (441x680, 295.5K)

p4 still seething that P5 is better

This, couldn't agree more. I proffered when Persona had darker undertones.

This is a good point, I liked how Garrus and Tali ended up together if you didn't romance either of them, maybe this will be a thing in the next Persona.

Attached: F901E03C-2521-4408-A686-DF49BA95BE04.jpg (642x1024, 109.43K)

>If you think P4 is "soul" you are a zoomer, period.
I had already graduated high school when P4 came out and it's my 2nd favorite after 2EP.

Maybe Joker just wanted to be stepped on by lolis?

Ziodynecock bangs a nurse milf, checkmate.

So not only is he a virgin loser, but also a sexual deviant. I can see why he's so relatable to P5fags.

>NPCs feel like people in P4
>literally stand in the middle of the road doing nothing
I love P4 but I feel little connection to the NPCs and even the SLinks. Yu just has to say the one right thing every now and then whereas Joker is an actual participant in his.

She acts like she's in control and then runs away like a little bitch, counter-check.

>literally stand in the middle of the road doing nothing
You've never lived in a rural area, have you?

the problem with p5 is its too damn long, im playing Royal right now and getting close to 60+ hours in and I've only beaten 3 palaces, the twists in the story are too obvious to justify the length, you can tell whats going to happen by the time you beat Kaneshiro but I have to sit around while these idiot teens act retarded and do nothing to find out about the other metaverse user

The insecurity of P4fags 10 years later is absolutely unreal