A game full of shit like this is not a 10/10 masterpiece. There are dozens more examples

Abby should have been dead in this confrontation multiple times, the most obvious being when she's strangling Ellie, who then pulls a knife, and instead of stabbing her in any number of vital areas while Abby's hands are occupied, stabs her in the fucking thigh.

the plain fact of the matter is the entire story is poorly done. they could have killed off joel but they spent no time building any sort of emotional connection to abby. so theres no way anyone would ever side with her or even understand what she did. everyone is just going to hate her for killing top dad

Attached: 1589154561374.png (1266x688, 407.01K)

You're doing it wrong. To start a LOU2 thread on Zig Forums, you are supposed to say the opposite stance of what you want, in order to enrage everyone into posting and you can them join the masses behind the Anonymous username.

Next thread start it with "Casual filter, BTFO" and it will hit bump limit.

>Its hard to stab someone

uhh...no

>call porkchop
heh

Quail man won’t stand for this bullshit

The only example you need of anything to point out that the story is shit is that it's supposed to be a tale about the cycle of revenge and how that's bad, and yet the person who carries out their revenge loses nothing from it while the person who gives up on their revenge loses everything.

>noooo why are these characters in this grindhouse revenge porn story not acting hyper rationally like i am noo

Attached: lvlt7dvi0V1qzqhv2.jpg (500x375, 35.59K)

>and get your knife back
you forgot that part faggot. if someone is fighting you actively you could end up jamming it in somewhere where you wont get it back.

Stabbing her in the thigh the way she did would almost undoubtedly be fatal given the circumstances if the game was actually trying to be realistic, albeit not immediately.

>we want to tell a human story and depict realistic violence and gore
>NO STOP LIKING THE EVIL WHITE DAD HE KILLED PEOPLE
>STOP CRITIQUING THE REALISM WE JUST MADE IT LOOK REAL

Attached: 1586127657149.png (362x376, 26.66K)

Attached: 1589250038664.jpg (1266x688, 180.31K)

>grindhouse revenge porn
I thought it was supposed to be Schindler's List

it's a videogame, it's not realistic in the first place. Any claim of realism is done by the audience, not the author.

Maybe her gun was in a different room wow so hard

Attached: 1589155932021.png (1266x688, 461.85K)

Because if she shot abby she would be just as bad as her

why would she not have her gun on her given the situation

and?

you´ve already stabbed her, more than enought of an advantage to win the fight, specially after Abby was already tired of fighting Ellie

Only according to Zig Forums

no the author(s) said they wanted to depict realistic violence my man. they did "research" or are you just conveniently ignoring that?

Maybe she didn't know where it was because she was sick? Maybe she didn't have time to grab it because she was seconds away from killing ellie? Man you guys would suck at writing if you had the chance, thank god you won't.

maybe she just forgot about her gun duh

Uh, doesn't abby lose all of her friends and end up 10 years a slave where she loses all her gains?

Actually they spend half the game trying to make you sympathize with Abby, it's forced down your throat.

I can just tell you that even with next to no combat experience, I would know to go for something like the neck, eye, or something like that. She would be done instantly.

Bullets are scarce in post-apocalypse.

>it's a videogame
a shit one at that, for the reasons shown ITT

Wasnt she just taking a nap when this happens? They just casually chill around the theater like its completely secure. That parts retarded but her being surprised and not having her gun on her in the moment isnt a crazy idea

Dina was constantly drinking and doing drugs while pregnant, not to mention getting viciously beat by Abby. Her baby is probably retarded.

>and yet the person who carries out their revenge loses nothing from it
Memes have rotted your feeble mind

no you dont. it depends on where you stabbed her, and a hardened tranny like abby hopped up on steroids isnt going to just stop with a blade in her unless its an actual vital spot

Why would you not having a gun all the time on you in a world full of zombies?

Game is a masterpiece plebeian

They don't nickname him Potato for nothin

after joel is killed yes and its broken up by flashbacks. you are given no room or time to like abby before she goes golfing

She doesn't lose Lev, who is the most important person to her. And she's captured for less than a year.

Hello contrarian.

a pleb would think this is a masterpiece its gameplay is good when the story gets out of the way but the story is trash

giving you the benefit of the doubt that that's true, which I don't believe it is considering the amount of stab wounds routinely clocked on murdered people, one good stab to a vital area would be infinitely more effective than even a dozen superficial surface slashes.

nigger if someone stabs me anywhere besides the face, heart, lungs, or one of the organs in my abdomen im still fighting. Adrenaline at that point would nullify 90% of pain so if you're first stab isnt lethal anyone would still be fighting back.

The entire story hinges on everyone ignoring logic and acting stupid.

She actually loses her pistol when she falls through the skylight. This is retarded.

So let me get this straight.
>pushes up glasses
Han Solo is a smuggler.
A smuggler being a man who sneaks around and tries not to get caught with illegal goods. That's his job. Sneaking around.
>laughs
Are you telling me that Han Solo, a smuggler on the UNIVERSE's biggest enemy battlestation... With hundreds of thousands of enemy troops...
>snorts
You're telling me that Star Wars is a good movie... even though Han Solo the smuggler says "I'm tired of all this sneaking around"
>vomits from laughter and disgust