Between Melee and Brawl, which artstyle did you prefer? I feel some characters looked better in Brawl like Samus...

Between Melee and Brawl, which artstyle did you prefer? I feel some characters looked better in Brawl like Samus, Falcon, and Luigi but others like Mario, Fox, Jigglypuff, and Peach looked better in Melee, overall which do you like more graphically?

Attached: maxresdefault.jpg (1280x720, 174.05K)

Melee in terms of soul and accuracy, despite some flaws here and there or limitations when it comes to textures and materials, for the most part they nailed character appearances, voices and movements, including many of the trophies. Characters felt the most like what Nintendo used to represent.

Melee has a unique artstyle so I feel like it's unfair to compare it to the other games in the series.
But if I had to choose, 3DS

Link was equally as cute in both. They really fucked him up in 4, and I guess ultimate is ok but I prefer the OOT and TP incarnations of Link so the first 3 were just the best.

Brawl with Dolphin enhancements

between melee, brawl, 4 and ultimate, which group has molested children?

Why does that make it unfair to compare? That makes 0 sense. Just admit melee has the best style and holds up amazingly

Just melee and brawl? Melee looks for sure

I like melee’s cheap plastic look because it makes the characters look like toys which they’re supposed to be

They all look good

I'm still annoyed that DK and Bowser aren't allowed to have any personality in smash and are just monsters that grunt instead. Would it kill them to at least use the noises they actually make in their games instead of stock gorilla sound effects.

They try to accomplish two different things. I don't even like to compare games of different genres desu.

Based

I prefer the realism of Brawl a lot more

Why between brawl and melee? 4 and ultimate have a better art style and is more true to the characters.
Remember how ugly pic related is in melee?

Attached: Yoshi_SSBM.jpg (200x266, 12.68K)

Melee had the most consistency between characters

Attached: original 8.png (1100x2100, 1.43M)

God no, modern DK’s voice is fucking horrible

SOUL
SOULLESS
SOUL-LITE

Brawl, I like the gritty shading they went with

>Melee in terms of soul and accuracy
Melee has some insanely off-model characters, though. Brawl fucked with the color and texture of some things, but everything perfectly matched the reference sheets.

Bowser at least has the excuse of being based on his N64 incarnation. DK and Diddy still making gorilla noises instead of having Banjo like cartoon sounds is stupid

I still can't believe that my dumb ass thought Brawl looked good all those years ago.

melee but brawl is still amazing really miss it

Everyone was obsessed with realistic graphics back in those days, being able to see the individual stitches on Mario’s overalls was the coolest shit to me

To me, him having stock gorilla sound effects is just as bad. At least his face is expressive in the newer games.
It would be great if bowser actually had the sound effects from 64 then instead of discount godzilla noises. Having the laugh from 64 on a taunt would be fucking great.

>Melee has some insanely off-model characters, though
like who? They're all based on the N64 era designs save for characters like Samus and Marth

Ultimate is just Wii U but going overboard with lighting so it looks good undocked but shit on TV

I miss how toad and dk used to sound like in mk64

Yoshi and Mewtwo

And Wii U is just Brawl with more saturated colors what your point?

The biggest loss was Mario Party 2 Wario's VA being axed