Can video games be art?

Can video games be art?

Attached: ss.png (1049x632, 951.87K)

yes. next thread

Yes

no. next thread

3pbp

why is it important to you or anyone?
want to win imaginary prizes?
if it is or if it isn't, does it make a difference to you?
if it does, why?
why are you like this?
what does it even matter to you?
why can't you observe the world through your thoughts?

stfu schizo

no and you dont want it to be art
this whole fucking "is vidja art" made it infested with art degree liberal niggers shitting up the games, it also allowed jews to fuck the games up with microtransactions cuz "i guess vidja is legit medium its art so I can play vidja" said the faggot consoomer
if games stayed like they were in the 90s full of gore and simple but satisfying mechanics everything would be fine but NOOOO fun wasnt enough, it has to be """""ART""""""

Attached: doom2.jpg (1280x720, 180.61K)

no.

games can contain art, but the product itself is not an art

why not

Shut the fuck up you smartass 16 year old who discovered Doom for the first time.

nice projections nigger now go buy your battle pass and dont forget to #freeforthnite

you can't answer my questions and are now distancing yourself from the by insulting me thinking you'll get away by closing your eyes to such facts
let me say it in a way a dog like you could even understand, pussy ass nigga don't know 'bout my kicks[/spoiler[

all video games are art. anything that gets specifically labeled as art usually just attracts people who don't care about gameplay and need their egos inflated by letting everyone know they appreciate "real art".

Attached: r3opvzdl5uz21.jpg (416x416, 23.75K)

>Can video games be art?
Yes, and handful of them has already achieved such recognition.

Yeah, because microtransactions aren't an invention of mass multiplayer casual shooters and aren't primarily pushed by major AAA corporations promoting games primarily as a service. It's the art fags who are to blame!

The real question is: why does it frighten you so?

Attached: MeatProject.jpg (1920x1080, 486.3K)

name 1 good game that you consider art

sitting on your HDD, is TLOU2 still being art?

if the files are corrupted and it won't load, is it still art?

A game is a system, it's purpose is to function according to it's programming.

Art exists.

Games are perhaps art in the sense of performance but that would be on the side of the player, like actors performing a play.

>name 1 good game that you consider art
The pic related didn't give it away?
Pathologic 2

With that said, what I personally want to consider art isn't all that important. I may have a bit more authority and influence on the subject than most people around here, but not nearly enough to actually make a serious impact on the discourse.

Attached: ThisIsJustNormal.jpg (1920x1080, 204.41K)

pathalogic plays like garbage and its a bad game by definition
also its the go to fart sniffer game and half who claims its "serious art guys!!!" never played it and just parrots youtube essays

Did I at any point indicate that I care about your opinion?

Video games aren’t art. Gaming is art.

you are posting on Zig Forums nigger,why even post if you dont want others to respond insecure dumbass lol

I care about opinions of people that have something interesting to say, or about particular mental illnesses that they suffer. What neither I nor ANYONE else on this board gives a fuck about is you saying how you dislike something. It does not make you interesting - nobody cares, nobody will care. You have LITERALLY nothing to say.

>nooo only say what I care about nooo why dont you contribute to my personal echo chamber noooo
I know just the site for you my 14 year old friend..

Rarely. A game where you gun down bunch of enemies can never be art.

What games you like, pleb?

No. Not unless you are a weirdo and count chess or basketball as art.

Games contain art, but they themselves are not art, because they are games.

>I know just the site for you my 14 year old friend..
Kid, keep deluding yourself that people don't give a fuck about you because you hurt their feelings, and not because you are just that fucking boring.

Have you looked around lately? Saying GAME IS SHIT is just white noise here. It's little more than few extra steps in the process of pressing "submit".

You. Are. BORING. That is really the problem. No matter how much you delude yourself, you aren't offending anyone, you aren't edgy cool kid going against the crowd:
You are literally the dullest, most uninventive sheeple around these lands. Doing the exact same mechanical thing 90% of all the boring shitposters around here do. Why would you think anyone is going to care for your opinion in particular?

>sitting on your HDD, is TLOU2 still being art?

I'd like to say yes to this but you specified TLOU2. Let's just pretend you said any other game. :)

>if the files are corrupted and it won't load, is it still art?

Yes! If a painting is destroyed does it mean it wasn't art before being destroyed? Heck there are games that intentionally corrupt themselves as part of the experience.

>A game is a system, it's purpose is to function according to it's programming.

A system created by humans. The functions designed by humans. Its purpose determined by humans.

RCT2 is my favorite game of all time

>Games contain art, but they themselves are not art, because they are games.
Literature can't be art, because it's literature. Movies can't be art because they are movies. Dance can't be art because it's a dance.

Great line of argumentation you have there, champ.

I am not reading your reddit spaced diarrhea faggot

Yes, but the label of "art" does not carry any inherent denotation of quality.
The Mona Lisa and my shitty stick figure scribbles from when I was 6 are both "art", but are of clearly different quality.

Attached: 1571384774228.jpg (480x360, 16.72K)

Thank you.

Good. Fuck off then. This really isn't the place for you.

Based

In theory, yes.
In practise, no.

The people capable of making art don't want to, and the people that want to can only ape the most shallow aspects of other artistic platforms.

Art is just a meaningless buzzword for people to try to appeal to some external value of a game that they can't properly justify other than referring to some artificial set of principles that they think matter. It's the same set of magical principles people refer to when they talk about "themes" and shit of something they think has more merit than the outside would suggest when it really doesn't and that person is just grasping at magical straws that don't exist outside of their idealistic thinking.

Attached: 1595236062898.jpg (1080x1212, 338.68K)

no. They can be beautiful and contain artistry, but a game is something separate from art.

Does it matter at this point? The word art is entirely meaningless. These days art is supposedly everything, which just makes it a synonym for everything.
It's basically the same as asking "does video games exist".

We need a new word for "creative works in a classical field that requires a medium amount of skill to produce", because that word is actually somewhat useful.