Should Telltale have given the player the option to kill her?

Should Telltale have given the player the option to kill her?
Surely it would make sense in the context of the game itself.

Attached: STC_Clem_10.jpg (830x1003, 221.34K)

No, making Clem's death determinant would've automatically invaldiated that route as the 'bad end' by the majority of the playerbase regardless of any other consequences involved so it would never have worked properly as a decision. Giving Clementine a happy ending was peak SOUL

Yes, because amputation isn't enough to save you from a bite. We saw this already with Sarita and Lee.

Except it is enough sometimes, as we've seen with Reggie and Abel

Abel turned though, assuming you didn't mercy kill him

not really

What? Abel turns because he dies from internal bleeding after being thrown from the balcony. If Clem fights him and gets him bitten in episode 1 then he cuts off his arm and is fine the next episode

She did die, and they brought her back to life somehow. She turned in the barn.

Everyone who dies turns FFS. Did you even play the game?

Do you even know what fucking conversation is being had here, retard? The post wasn't about people turning after they died, it was about whether an amputation can save someone from a bite

This poster is retarded

Stupid fucking cunt

You fucking dumb nigger. Abel doesn't die unless you kill him or he succumbs to his injuries

...What the fuck are you talking about you utter retard? Read the fucking comment thread

Didn't like these games. They have the same problems you always find in Anglo games: derivative plots, lots of Hollywood clichés and tropes, uninteresting, generic characters, cheap drama that takes itself way too seriously...

Did you even play the game, cunt?

That would involve giving the player a measure of actual, meaningful agency, which means more work for the devs.
Can't have that, they needed to shit out the game before the company went under.

He knows.
See how many times you can make him double-down

You're an idiot. Just be quiet

How can I make her safe, lads?

Attached: 8c21880224abb93472f34b8d4ce21990.jpg (604x604, 72.99K)

Fucking make me pipeworker.

Complete season 4 and trust AJ to make his own decisions

Someone post the vocaroo

Is it lewd

Should Telltale have given the player the option to impregnate her?
Surely it would make sense in the context of the game itself.

AJ is a dumb jogger though.

Need Clem to do her Circle, Triangle manoeuvre on my bollocks

>When Clem mashes Q on you
Oh baby

Would love to toe punt that lil niglet into a heard

Of course it would work as a decision. You had the choice to take Lee's life in the first season and it worked. Why not Clem's?

They should've made it depending on AJ education. If you told him to be merciful wee would shoot her to spare her a walker life. If you told him to be cold-ass bitch he would save the bullet for himself and run off, while Clem would be rescued by others who would amputate her leg and both survive..

Attached: 1598567932639.png (1920x1080, 1.84M)

Lee dies either way, the decision is whether to shoot him or let him turn. If season 4 had multiple endings, one of them with Clementine alive and another with Clementine dead, then there would be an objective good end and bad end which is stupid