P3>p4>p5

P2IS>P2EP>P4>P5>P3>P1
Trust me, i actually played them

>What is the kid by the map in the classroom?

Attached: 1553190764113.jpg (2000x1568, 309.04K)

P5R>P4G>P3FES

Attached: Takuto_enemy.png (566x668, 212.01K)

this

P5 = P3 > P4

>le old good new bad meme

that's for fast travel around the school which saves you only a marginal amount of time. There's still a fucking grip of time totally wasted moving between all the different locations you actual black.

Agreed

absolutely this. I'll also never understand the complaints of its pacing either. It's the only Persona game I feel that's consistently engaging the whole way through. In P3 things don't really picky up until July, and in P5 things just get boring from Kaneshiro up until Sae

You're complaining about wasting time in an RPG series that easily span 100 hours each game.

tbf there's a lot of wasted time running around in fes. It's a good game but there's a lot of unnecessary running around. If you don't give a shit about the cutscenes or the answer just play p3p

There's a lot of wasted running around in all of the games, FES just has more of it because it was their first attempt at what modern Persona should be. Having to apologize to other social links because you dared to hang out with other social links was tedious, but it made sense and added more strategy than just being jerked off by everyone like latter Persona games. That's half the reason why I can't get into 4 or 5, it's just a self masturbation simulator. FES was great in that the characters were written realistically and didn't suck the MC off but instead grew to like and trust him over the course of the game. It felt like how actual relationships form, and as such I think it's the closest to Carl Jung's work (besides the first two) that the Persona games managed to get to.

While it's true, Yuko/Chidori carried Persona 3. The rest of the confidents were pretty horrible (aside from the old couple and girl in the park). When you have "That Hippie" and no real side activities, it led to boredom.

Honestly, we need a Persona that has multiple protagonists and separate playthroughs. Except GOOD protaganists. I can just imagine Atlus making two protagonists either evil or terrible to play.

Attached: Yuko.jpg (1280x720, 132.64K)

That would go against what Persona is supposed to be. The two protagonists makes more sense in SMT, but even then that's stretching it.

>That would go against what Persona is supposed to be
Hell that would go against Atlus's design philosophy in general since pretty much all SMT/Persona games do silent protagonists.

I mean yeah? It's a 100 hour game. Wasting your time by such means is an absolutely valid complaint

KIMI WA NE>OWARANAI HIBI>>NEVER MORE

why didn't they add quick travel to FES?

stfu fes would literally be 50 hours with sane fast travel menus

I literally said it in the first few sentences, you ADD retards. Holy fuck stop acting like children.

theres nothing big brain by wasting peoples time.

No one said that retard.

P3 > P2 > P5 > P4

I like P4's setting though

4>2>3>5

Attached: takaya gun.png (624x567, 477.67K)

>why didn't they add quick travel to FES
It was their first take on modern persona and quick travel wasn't a huge mechanic at the time of its inception you zoomer

This, P4 is the most all-round good of the nu trilogy.

You can say that about any game. What's your point? That you don't want to waste time in a medium about wasting time?

>no BE CONFIDENT THINK POSITIVE

Attached: file.png (262x297, 138.1K)

Too bad it's stapled onto the bad base game.

>sane fast travel menus
wtf does this even mean how can menus be sane?

3 doesn't even have a story up until november

He's just an idiot, ignore him.

yeah this isn't some grand statement or brilliant level design. p3 fes did some shit way wrong that was corrected in later titles. Not having fast travel wastes a ton of time, the tired mechanic is fucking stupid, the social links while I will admit there is some strategy to it if you plan on doing multiple playthroughs and get the benefit of having max social stats out the gate. However the schedule on a first playthrough is tighter than a nun's asshole and having to save scum/go back to get the optimal answers is fucking stupid and another giant waste of time.
>I think it's the closest to Carl Jung
oh fuck off and go back you faggot

Attached: 1579240716830.png (154x219, 32.72K)

IMASUUUUUUUUGU NI
WARATTE AGEEEEEMASHOU

youtube.com/watch?v=Z9pUx3LHU4E

Attached: 1461735722741.jpg (528x575, 68.43K)

>shitting on carl jung

P5R>P3F>P4G
None of them are bad games by any means.

Reminder that Jung was canonically the first Persona user

Attached: .png (1280x720, 1.9M)

>yeah this isn't some grand statement or brilliant level design
Was that even said or implied? I swear half of you persona/smt fans are pseudo-intellectuals that are actually retards that can't even follow a basic post.
>oh fuck off go back you faggot
We're talking about Persona you idiot, obviously SMT touches on this better but that's not what the topic is about.

P3>P5R>P4G>P4>P5

He couldn't even quote the correct post user. Cut him some slack.