Rank the 3D Mario games

rank the 3D Mario games

Attached: Ranking-the-Super-Mario-games-1200x900.jpg (1200x900, 134.74K)

odyssey > all

Sunshine > all

No

Odyssey >all>shit >sunshine

2>1>3>prequel>remake

They're all S tier.

64 > Odyssey = Sunshine > Galaxy games
64 is the most balanced experience there is, and its fun enough to get good at. Getting good at Mario is fullfilling and the game is generally well designed with only a few stinkers ( Water Levels are never fun )
Odyssey is also that aforementioned aspect, but it's basically just that. The game is practically devoid of proper level design, and 99% of it if not all of it feels like it was designed for Mario without Cappy. Also Captures are a shit gimmick.
Sunshine also has pretty fun movement that's pretty unique & is fullfilling to get good at, but it's rough around the edge, too rigid in its progression, and has more stinkers than 64.
The Galaxy Games are well designed but they're too shallow & slow. They're good on 1st playthrough & still good games but there's little of value that comes with replaying the games.

Galaxy 2 > 64 > Galaxy 1 > Sunshine > Odyssey > 3D Land > 3D World

True

what about land and world?

I don't remember much of 3D Land, and I didn't play 3D World despite having had a Wii U
I wasn't that much into gaming despite somehow having a Wii U back then, and like everyone, I fell for the bad rep the game got when its first trailers showed generic looking grasslands

The non-linear ones > the linear ones

64 > Shunshine > Galaxy 2 > Galaxy 1 >>>>>>>>>>>Odyssey
Fuck Odyssey. It's the most generic, bland mediocre game I have ever played.

The one I remember enjoying the most was Galaxy. Sunshine's alright.
Haven't played 64 in ages. Odyssey and 3D world were mediocre.

Worst 3D Mario is 3D Land and I sometimes even forget that it wasn't just a tiny spinoff game.

Galaxy 2 > 64 >Odyssey > 3d world> Mario Galaxy > Sunshine > 3d land

why do you dislike land? I only just beat the first world but it feels like a really cool experiment so far

64>Galaxy 2>Sunshine>Galaxy1>Odyssey>3D World
all competent games, but some are just moreso than the others

It feels like a worse version of 3D World in retrospect and that is already a game I only really like when playing with friends.

GOAT:
Super Mario 64

Outstanding:
Super Mario Sunshine, Super Mario Odyssey

Great:
Super Mario Galaxy, Super Mario Galaxy 2

Good:
Super Mario 3D Land

Haven't played ;_;:
Super Mario 3D World

Sunshine > Galaxy > 64 > Odyssey > the others i guess

galaxy 2>odyssey>galaxy>3d world>sunshine>64

64 > Odyssey > Galaxy = Sunshine >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3d land/world

galaxy 2 > 64 > galaxy =/> 3d world > odyssey > 3d land > sunshine
sunshine became my least favourite after 100%ing it recently (wasn't hard at all which surprised me, but it was tedious and just didn't have enough platforming)
waiting to replay 3d world via the port on switch to see if i prefer it to galaxy now.

3D Land > Odyssey > Galaxy 2 > Galaxy > 64 >>>>>> Sunshine

64>Odyssey>3D world (in co op)>galaxy 2>galaxy 1>sunshine

3d land>galaxy>galaxy 2>odyssey>sunshine>64>3d world

Odyssey=64>Galaxy1+2>Sunshine>3D World>3D Land

I'm sorry but sunshine just feels sluggish and boring to me. My only issue with Odyssey is that the hat jump is so good that once you figure it out, its pretty much the only thing you ever use for anything.

Attached: 1567345389432.png (554x439, 44.74K)

64>Odyssey>who cares

Fpbp
Thread should have ended here

hope we get an odyssey 2 which is more focused like galaxy 2 was.
it'd be kino (based too, if they added luigi as a playable character)

i don't think he feels sluggish at all. it's more that he feels really fucking sensitive and just rockets off as soon as you tilt the stick a bit.