So a Japanese game I'm working on now has an unfortunate joke where the premise/punchline is basically just "lol being gay is weird/bad." I find it offensive and distracting, and honestly I kind of want to just remove or rewrite it. Like, even great writers can be callous at times, and even great works can be marred by bigotry and insensitivity. This is an unavoidable fact of life and something healthy to acknowledge. But at the same time I know this particular bit isn't really important to the overall narrative and will definitely bother a subset of readers. So should I push for it to be changed?
So a Japanese game I'm working on now has an unfortunate joke where the premise/punchline is basically just "lol being...
based japs, homosexuality is a mental disorder
Fuck off faggot
Yo you can't just say that here. Most people here on Zig Forums are homos so they are going to SEETHE at your post.
Fuck off, homophobe.
>says the virgin who jerks off to drawings of children
>so I'm reading To Kill a Mockingbird, and can't help but notice the constant use of the word "nigger."
etc etc
Either way dumb LARP, shit thread, remember what to put in the options field in shit threads.
bring it up that it'd go over real fucking poorly everywhere else in the world and if the joke is worth alienating customers over
That's an old book from a period where being a bigot wasn't seen as a bad thing. This is a 21th century Japanese game and the translation is aimed at modern progressive western audience who is very sensitive to this shit. What if they cancel the game?
>Doesn't refute it being a mental disorder
BASED
Fpbp
>translation is aimed at modern progressive western audience
these people dont play games
Even if they don't play games, they are extremely vocal and controversy friendly.
Good. I mean, I learnt about Dragon's Crown and Nier Automata and a whole slew of videogames through their outrage and had the time of my life playing those games. Vocal SJWs + unrelenting based devs = guaranteed good times for me.
Keep Kumiko out of this garbage.
braindead kumiko poster
well is it funny? Try to push for a funnier joke that insults them.
I don't even believe this is real, so yeah, sure, push for it to be changed.
Change it, EOP should always be punished with an inferior product.
Depends, will you let me fuck your boypussy?
Change it. They're the ones who made a fuckup, and fuckups should be fixed.
Evidently someone made a mistake.
Your parents, since they didn't abort you.
Yes, you should!
Posting in a bait thread
I know this thread is bait but I know for a fake discussions like this exist at sony commiefornia hq.
Persona 4 made fun of Kanji for his supposed homosexuality and I thought that was really funny. You should keep the joke in, user.
Cool, what game was it?
I don't think its right to change the original's work to fit your own beliefs but i'm just user on a basketweaving image forum
absolutely not.
and never use kumiko to post ever again
No you should stay loyal to the original intent of the creator. If you find yourself incapable of doing so give it so someone else to translate.
God damned proglodyte.
Going to assume you're not a troll and give you real advice. Let people be bothered, and let them direct their criticism to the actual writers instead of pretending to be a writer yourself. All you're doing by "fixing" this is insulating the writers from getting any feedback on this themselves. Don't trust yourself to have a full understanding of what the author's intentions are either. Everyone who reads it could come away with a different takeaway. Yours is not necessarily the only interpretation.
If you can, phrase things in such a way that that's still one possibile interpretation of the joke, but it's also vague enough to be interpreted in other ways. Then you've got the best of both worlds.
>implying they would even entertain the idea of not changing it