CAMPAIGNS ONLY
Gameplay:
CE > 3 > 2 > Reach > ODST
Story:
2 > CE > ODST > 3 > Reach
Atmosphere:
CE >ODST > 2 > 3 > Reach
Level Design:
Reach > 3 > CE > 2
CAMPAIGNS ONLY
James Evans
Landon Clark
>Gameplay
3 > ODST > 2 > 1 > Reach
>Story
2 > 3 > ODST > Reach > 1
>Writing
2 > 1 > ODST > 3 > Reach
>Atmosphere
ODST > 1 > Reach > 2 > 3
>Level Design
3 > Reach > 1 > ODST > 2
Justin Butler
>thinking the first game in the series has the best gameplay
literally how
Oliver Roberts
The atmosphere on Floodgate, The Ark, The Covenant, Cortana and Halo was fucking great. Also Reach's level design was mediocre at best, I can remember the layouts of most Halo campaign maps but none for Reach except Sword Base. Apart from that I agree with you.
John Garcia
Covenant AI only got worse. Weapons felt the best.
Julian Mitchell
I was surprised by Reach desu. I replayed it for the first time in literal years recently and the variety of the levels as well as their design actually stood out to me. Contrasted pretty hard with CE's copy and paste.
Kevin Cruz
>Gameplay
2 > CE > ODST > 3 > Reach
>Story
2 > ODST > CE > 3 > Reach
>Atmosphere
ODST > CE > 2 > 3 > Reach
>Level Design
2 > 3 > ODST > Reach > CE
Joseph Ross
This is all after playing every game in PC
>Gameplay
3 >Reach> ODST > 2 > 1
Yes because armor abilities aren't relevant in single player
>Story
2 > 3 == ODST > Reach > 1
What can I say, it was a hell of a night
>Writing
2 > ODST > 3 > Reach > 1
Not by that much mind you
>Atmosphere
ODST == 1 == Reach == 2 > 3
>Level Design
Reach > 3 > 1 == 2 > ODST
Lincoln Gomez
Reach didn't have any atmosphere in-game, it was designed like a sandbox and all the voice actors sound bored. The cutscenes had plenty of atmosphere but that's cheating.
Grayson Sanders
the variety is due to gimmicks and setpieces. fuck the reach campaign tbqhwyf
David Harris
Multiplayer:
CE > Halo 3 (for custom stuff) > rest
Leo Johnson
>ah yes, the AI in this copy and pasted corridor is so enjoyable
cope CE fag, 2 is better in every regard
Cooper Martinez
>Yes because armor abilities aren't relevant in single player
But even then Reach just plays like a clunkier and shittier 3.
Dylan Morris
>gimmicks and setpieces
yes they made the campaign more varied. Each level felt very different to the last. The only one that stood out as poor was The Package IMO.
Gavin Jenkins
Do you like how I seperated gameplay and level design for that exact reason you cocksmoker. The core "30 seconds of fun" can still be good regardless of level design.
Andrew Baker
I actually found the first 3-4 missions to be too similar.
Michael Green
>Reach having better story/writing than 1
Halo 1 is simplistic space opera but at least it makes sense. Ignoring the book autism stuff, Reach's story has more holes than swiss cheese. It is dumb as fuck.
Easton Baker
To be fair I don't think there is anyone saying it has bad atmosphere. Oozing with soul is literally what carried the Bungie Halo games. All of them.
Adrian Howard
3 > CE > 2 > 4 > 5
Don't care about the rest since they're not part of the main series. Infinite should be an interesting one, very excited about it.
Alexander Nelson
>counts 4 and 5 but ignores ODST and reach
okay retard
Nathaniel Gomez
>doesn’t care about because not part of main series
>unironically puts 4 and 5 on the list
Luis Gutierrez
3 has the worst gameplay, anyone who puts 3 at the top of the list is retarded. The shooting is terrible and non responsive
Joshua Reyes
>Gameplay
ODST > 3 > Reach > 2 > CE
>Story
CE > 2 > ODST > 3 > Reach
>Writing
2 > CE > ODST > 3 >Reach
>Atmosphere
ODST > CE > Reach > 3 > 2
>Level design
3 > ODST > CE > Reach > 2
>Multiplayer
3 > 2 > Reach > CE (ODST doesnt have multiplayer)
>Overall favorite
3 > CE > ODST > Reach > 2
Jeremiah Watson
>Gameplay
3>2>ODST>Reach>1
>Story
2>1>3>Reach>ODST
>Atmosphere
ODST>1>Reach>3>2
>Level Design
3>Reach>ODST>1>2
Zachary Bennett
and yet you still wont admit 2's level design, while still shitty, isn't better than the dumpster fire that is CE's level design.
I can practically smell the roses from the tint of your glasses.
Dylan Anderson
No Chief, don't give a fuck, plus both are boring as shit with Reach being better ODST.
Daniel Rodriguez
Ah man I like all these games how am I supposed to choose
Ian Martin
Gameplay:
Reach > 3 > 2 > ODST
Story:
3 > 2 > ODST > Reach > CE
Atmosphere
ODST > 2 > 3 > Reach
Level Design
Reach > ODST > 3 > 2
Luke Baker
based
Leo Cook
>Gameplay
CE for Arcade feel, Reach all around
>Enemies
Reach
>Sandbox
Either CE or 3
>Level Design
3
>Story
2 by far
>Atmosphere
CE or ODST
Zachary Lee
based
Matthew Adams
Best campaign missions, in order:
>The Ark
>Silent Cartographer
>The Covenant
>Delta Halo
>Long Night of Solace