Was he Death?

Was he Death?

Attached: Odd Fellow.jpg (1280x720, 91.65K)

he was you

He was Trelawney who is said to be a magician. He used magic to erase John's memory of him, Arthur, and the rest of the gang.

No, just some bloke

He's God
>Damn you!
>Many people have

he was the devil, no? or was he god, hence the "many have" to john saying damn you.

He's death, Azrael, the grim reaper.
You find a note about him in RDR2 explaining how he's seen overlooking the town of armadillo like the reaper dressed in his sunday best.

I always assumed death. He doesn't encourage John to do good or evil, just observes

He's Marston's inner self.

this was so fucking cool. sometimes i wish we could get a whole game of morality questions.

He's god.

I encouraged the man, in the first scenario, to fuck the proustite. In my world that is morally right. You know why? Because pleasure is hard to come by. And marriage is an artificial institution. So I dont see why its wrong, in this wasteland, to grab pleasure when it presents itself. I encouraged the man the fuck the hooker.

You're mentally ill.

He was just a regular guy. John had black bullets in his gun placed by Dutch

No he's not, he just has a different perspective. I disagree with him but he's not objectively wrong. He's probably a hedonist.

He was the trope of death. What killing becomes if you do it enough.

Attached: Snidely-with-Nell.jpg (398x300, 22.4K)

I respect this user.
pussywhipped faggot, fuck you

His perspective is the result of mental illness. He IS objectively wrong.

Death, or God. If he was the devil, he wasn't the sort of devil people typically think of.

He was Gavin.

>perspective
>objectively wrong
user you are retarded sorry.

Attached: obby.png (751x244, 13.38K)

Moral law exists independent of your mentally ill mind.

But he intervenes when he asks you to stop his "friend" from cheating on his wife in RDR 1.
Death wouldn't intervene with that kinda petty shit.
He's probably god or the devil, either of the two. Probably whoever the player decides he is, since he only asks for the favors but you can decide how they unfold

>"I hope my boy turns out just like you"
> "(Damn you) many have..."
>"You WILL be responsible (for your actions)"

He's clearly god passing judgement on John before he dies.

Not the user you were talking to, but try reading the image I attatched. I think it does a pretty good job of explaining objectivity to someone who doesn't understand it. Or consider watching a youtube video on it or something.

A mysterious stranger.

Try reading this, retard.

Attached: iu[1].jpg (900x603, 43.39K)

I guess I'll explain myself. I had an unusual upbringing. I grew up in a part of the world, where pleasure was discouraged at all times for the good of the tradition/people. And thus I developed an inherent disgust for anything that tried to regulate pleasure. I found myself, like Orwell, wanting things to be corrupt to the bones, and not caring. This world tries already, so hard, to limit our happiness and pleasure and satisfaction. So taking true, unguilty joy, in anything, is a political action. And one, that I embrace, happily. So, if a man wants to have sex, regardless of the societal institutions of marriage, I say, go for it! This world has already taken and demanded so much. This world has taken so much, that seeking all the pleasure you can is not even scratching the surface of what has been deprived from you through cultural demands. I told him, go with the hooker, and I hope he has a good time doing it.

I would rather read Batman or Tolkein if I wanted to read some fantasy shit.

Attached: 1525139125724.png (924x560, 48.41K)

>read this
>try to talk with person who is a fan of it about the questionable parts
>they just spit fanfiction at me for an hour
I don't get it

Maybe hes like Zeus or something

It bothers me immensely that I can't play this game at 60 fps.

>Moral law exists
No

THE. HUMAN. EYE. CAN"T. SEE. ABOVE. 30 FPS.

Catholics, not even once

i will pray for you both tonight

Can you pray for me to get a QT3.14GF while you pray for those two?
I'm lonely user

>emma watson plays noah's adoptive daughter
Man, I wanted to fuck her so bad when I was a kid. Now I look at her and feel nothing but disgust

I will masturbate to nuns tonight

She was best in Prisoner/Goblet desu

Man, I'm a Christfag and in the sense of religion I believe in an objective morality based in faith. But that isn't how the real world works and I cannot force people to adhere to that standard. He's not mentally ill, he's exercising the free will we are all given.

His choice is a result of mental illness.

Pretty refined taste, user.
I'm going to say Goblet, definitively. I liked her hair better in that than in Prisoner

Is that why you pause between each word typed?