Is P4G the Sonic CD of the Persona Series?
>A game that was only available in a system no one bought
>People said it was great because no one actually played it
>Now it's readily available in PC
>People realize it's worse than the previous / next one
Persona 4 CD Golden
It's better than 5 but worse than 3 tho
>People realize it's worse than the previous one
I haven't played it yet, but I saw plenty of people saying this since it first came out. People shitting on Marie was a common practice.
>People realize it's worse than the previous / next one
you need to be 18 or older to post here
sage doesn't go in all fields because Zig Forums x shits the bed when I use it in the name box for some reason but you get the point
Thank god I turned 18 yesterday
I am trying out this Zig Forums thing and getting fags seething
Am I doing good?
p3p > p4g > p3 > p4 > p3fes > p5 > p5r
It's by far the best game in the series. 3 is shit and 5 is good but terribly flawed. You just have shit taste.
>> p5 > p5r
Is this a Zig Forums meme or legit?
>contrarian Zig Forums shitting on p3
>nobody ranking 1, innocent sin or eternal punishment
normalfags
>It's not shit, everyone else is just wrong
Guess that Yukiko truly is the best waifu all along
P4 and P4G are pretty much the same game, Sonic CD is an unique game. Shitty comparison
Those aren't persona games, user
If you actually need to battle, and not spam weakness to get infinite turns while a waifu screams at you filling you with dopamine it's not a Persona game
retard
Fatlus has fully embraced fujoshit, P5R and IVA are only the start.
>P4 and P4G are pretty much the same game
>extra month of gameplay
>new dungeon
>new music
>new social links
>new events
>new areas
>new minigames
plus the minimal shit like new weathers and small additions to the monthly gameplay
yeah, pretty much the same
>>People realize it's worse than the previous / next one
The most common opinion i've seen involving P4G is that it's the best of the series but that P3 and P5 are also really good. I kinda agree with the sentiment, they're all good. But I only say that because i've played some truly terrible JRPG's. The worst moments of any of those 3 are fucking masterpieces in comparison, and as annoying as some of the cast that P5 has. they're perfect next to the trash Star Ocean 4 threw my way, except for Meracle, she was prime catpussy. Shame the game locked you into the most generic girl in the game.
There's more content in Royal, yes, but I wouldn't say it's particularly good content, especially the new story shit.
Yeah, the old content is still there and that's good, at least to me the new stuff really left a bad impression on me.
And yet, that guy placed P4G over P4, when golden's new content isn't good enough to make up for the fact that Marie is an absolute garbage character
P5R might be a scam, but at least it's a better version of P5 while P4G is just a shittier version of P4
>People said it was great because no one actually played it
Stop projecting, the game is great. It was better than P5 due to great story and characters, with a really comfy atmosphere and it's better than P3 because took the best mechanics of it and improved
I won't put P1 and P2 in the comparison because they're totally different in every aspect, almost like they're another spin-off
Marie should've been the FeMC of P4G, change my mind. Protip: Not really.
compared to the rerelease waifus like kasuemi and nukiko that came after she isn't so bad
>fully embraced fujoshit
All they have to do is put a villain/psychopath with some potentially exploitable weakness and that's it, girls will lap it up. Akechi with his murdering and mommy and daddy issues out the ass qualifies.
This
Going full retard with the plot to justify bringing the dead fuckboy back while the devs joke about him being married to the protag definitely qualifies.
>extra month of gameplay
That literally adds nothing relevant to the plot and is just more filler shit
>new music
like 4 new songs, woah
>new dungeon
Only 1 dungeon out of 9, and the dungeon is completely optional
>new social links
like, 3 new social links?
The core game itself remains unchanged, stop pretending these changes makes P4G a completely new experience, because it doesn't. Plot is the same, most of the dialogues are the same, most of the songs are the same, etc
When can we get a P3 definitive edition that has all the assets and content from FES and p3p in one game. (FemC , Controllable party members)
what games let me play as a trashy hot topic scene slut?
P4G was record breaking in sales for them. Thinking nobody played it is retarded
>Fatlus has fully embraced fujoshit
Based
>That literally adds nothing relevant to the plot and is just more filler shit
Marie is literally a central character to the story
>like 4 new songs, woah
wrong, plus I wouldn't even be mad if that were the case, the songs are fucking good
>Only 1 dungeon out of 9, and the dungeon is completely optional
not denying it
>like, 3 new social links
I'll help you on this one, it's actually 2
>The core game itself remains unchanged, stop pretending these changes makes P4G a completely new experience, because it doesn't. Plot is the same, most of the dialogues are the same, most of the songs are the same, etc
P4G isn't mean to be an entirely new game, it's meant to expand on what's already there and it does so very well, plus most of what you state is the same has changed including dialogs, story, gameplay and such
>mfw Atlus ports P3P to PC as is
mfw I already emulated P3P
>People realize it's worse than the previous / next one
Are you retarded, nigger?
Who would want that? P3P was shit and your tranny femc will never be canon.
Not this. 3 is the worst of Nu-sona. Nostalgiafags should KYS asap.
But Sonic CD is the second best classic Sonic game.
3&K