This is literally the most boring game ive ever fucking played. Why is it so praised...

>this game is shit
>NO U GOT FILTERED"!!!!!! MOVIE GAMES GOOOD!!!!
>But i like actual good movies
>I DONT BELIEVE UUUUUUUUUUUU

go play your interactive movie and continue to have shit taste. Alternatively, prove me wrong by explaining why im wrong and why the gameplay is good

then play a game focused on that, not every game has to be a bing bing wahoo
who even purposefully buys a cowboy simulator movie game and then complains he got a cowboy simulator movie game

found the seething platinumfag, go beg konami for a mgr sequel while posting cancer that rivals that of jojofags

Moreso it just genuinely annoys me how much praise shit like this, TLOU etc gets. People that give these types of games so much praise are killing gaming, moviegames were the biggest cancer to ever become common place in this industry, prove me wrong.

lawl you didnt even understand my one sentence.

I think I've seen this artist somewhere, name?

By far, in RDR 1 the shooting was atleast fun

Quite funny how RDR threads like this always just devolve into strawmans about how you dont like moviegames. No one ever actually defends the game or gives good reasons for why its good, they just get triggered that people dare criticize their gay brokeback mountain simulator

console user?

Have you considered not being an ADD zoomer?

Have you considered having good taste, and playing video games that actually want to be video games, and not just an excuse for movie industry rejects to tell their there straight to VHS tier stories?

the game sucks

Install 4chanx. 九十九円

>This is literally the most boring game ive ever fucking played.
Zoom zoom

>still no crack
surely this rockstar shit is easier to crack than the latest denuvo? lots of people are saying lately that it sucks so i really dont want to pay the overpriced cost but want to larp as a badboy serial killer cowboy at 50fps.

I don't even like TLOU at all and rdr2 although worth playing is something I wouldn't play ever again because yes, the epilogue is boring as fuck
Zig Forums seethes at muh cinematic games 24/7, yet they sell because, you know, people like it
boogeyman rockstar and meanie naughty dog arent coming to take away dmc or your mgr or bayo away from you, if it doesn't sell and the franchise dies it's on its audience

I do have good taste, which is why I like the game.

But only zoomers like rockstar games though? Prove me wrong. Anyone over the age of 25 who has actually grown up playing good games with a gameplay focus would see right through this BS

Prove me wrong.

What a highly original contrarian opinion that hasn't been said so much it might as well be a copypasta

Yeah but what im trying to figure out is why people like it.

>Controls like ass
>Gunplay and shooting is garbage
>story is only "good for a video game" at best
>Realism over fun
>Open world has been done better in a ton of other games with way better dynamic and emergent gameplay systems (horizon, BOTW)

Now tell me why any of this is wrong

...

Prove me wrong though. No one has done it yet. All people do is call zoomer and say i don't understand le epic movie games :^) and tell me to go play gameplay focused games that are actually good, but no actual argument in defense of RDR

It's because it can't be defended because it's shit

...

RDR2 is absolutely based. You filters out all the retards with absolute accuracy.

>This is literally the most boring game ive ever fucking played
stopped reading here. back to dark souls buttonmasher.

I'm a retard phoneposting from work, thaks tho

>good gameplay
>hitting buttons and killing shit
woah, never experienced that before. kys kid

another lonely NPC user...

I really do hate what Zig Forums has become. We've entered some bizzaro reallity wherein people are genuinely arguing that rockshit games are better than dark souls. Fucking hell this board has fallen. I called this shit back in like 2011 that not bullying normies and underages out would be a mistake.

it's the AtD of vidya

Attached: gug.jpg (490x736, 30.91K)

The filter continues its winning streak

You gotta have some god damn FAITH

What is filtering about it? being a bad game isn't a filter. I thought filter meant too difficult for people, but theres nothing challenging in the entire game

Fuck off third worlder

>arguing that rockshit games are better than dark souls.
it's a fucking fact you brainlet shit. You are a fucking normie, all you want from games is some artificial challenge in how skillful you are at mashing buttons. You are the cancer that's keeping the medium from becoming anything of worth that is more than a kids toy. And your utter normieness is even more reflected by using the standard "what has this board become, I member when it.." Fucking killyourself you boring piece of old shit.

can someone explain to me why aiming feels so clunky on PC? i cant put my finger on it but i cant seem to aim as accurately as i can in other games

lawl filtered

>Controls feel worse than a fucking PS1 resident evil
The Resident Evil games on Playstation are actually really responsive. RDR2 is complete trash that only casualfag retards with zero taste who have never played a real game in their life would enjoy.

Attached: This would've failed the mission in a modern Rockstar game.webm (640x480, 2.88M)

Probably the most cancerous post made all year.

man you're dumb

This game was never made for pc, unironically use a controller to get that sweet auto aim because you are gonna lose your mind trying to aim with the mouse

RDR1 was actually good. I wish RDR2 followed its footsteps instead of GTA V.

Instead of insult flinging, please just humor me and explain why its a good game then. Im all ears. Is it because you know its shit and have no argument?

Why do video games need to become more than fun toys to dick about with?

>Controls like ass
I find the controls to be as good as they can be mapped on a controller, I don't understand how people got filtered by the L2 use
>Gunplay and shooting is garbage
I agree
>story is only "good for a video game" at best
I disagree, the themes were well handled and the characters had enough presence to make them memorable while still standing by the genres staples, to me it feels like a modern day take on john ford movies. could be a worthwhile show if it wasn't a game
>Realism over fun
Yes, that's what it goes for
>Open world has been done better in a ton of other games with way better dynamic and emergent gameplay systems (horizon, BOTW)
I agree, this and railroading the missions too much were the biggest problems of the game

perhaps, but he's right

???? i had zero issues aiming with the mouse

He wants video games to be shitty movies for tasteless plebs.

It filters people who like playing actual games from open-world-muh-kino-story shit eaters.

What's the difference? RDR1 was literally just long riding segments between basic shooting gallery segments. GTA stripped of any semblance of mission variety.

Attached: 79659859_p0_master1200.jpg (1200x900, 809.37K)

Im genuinely convinced now that everyone agrees its a shit game because so far in this thread not a single person has defended it beyond "lol filtered", whislt missing what an actual fucking filter is. A filter is like lady butterfuly in sekiro, a roadblock that fucks over people that haven't learned the games mechanics properly. RDR2 has nothing like that.

Except RDR2 is not a movie game

Rdr1 didn't took itself way too seriously, there was also that fun slo mo duels which wasn't present in rdr2

>Not a movie game
>5 hours in
>At least 3 hours of custcenes/walk n talks

because the only people in here are dumb trogs and people stupid enough to humor them

Just take your adderall

>explain why its a good game
because like anything that is good, it's about something, or at least tries to be. The characters represent something, they're not just little girls in skirts that are also robots, or giant skeletons. It's also good because it's bold. Only retards like you who don't use their brain even once a day think that R* with all their money and fame isn't capable of making a generic gameplay that would please the army of morons like yourself. But they tried to make something new, something more subtle.
>Why do video games need to become more than fun toys to dick about with?
that's on you to find out, not me to tell you

...

It's a genuinely and indisputably great game, the fact you can't see it only reveals how shit your taste is. Everyone that isn't a tastelet likes it, it's a litmus test for whether you are one or not.

If the gameplay is not "roll and attack with le generic melee weapon ad infinitum" then it's dog shit

yeah man persona 4 has so much gameplay

>start a mission
>rail horseride to destination
>it’s part of the gameplay
fuck off

Why would i waste time with movie industry rejects silly pet projects, when i could watch actual genuine movies with good stories.

If i want to watch a movie, ill watch a movie. If i want to play a game ill play a game. Whys that hard to comprehend?

Then explain what is so "genuinely and indisputably great" about it. I can sit here and say that kinglseys adventure on the PS1 is indisputably great but frankly its the only abomination i've ever played that was worse than RDR

It is the definition of movie game.

I played poker & fished more than robbing carriages or homesteads

Not OP and not even played RDR but why do video games, or any medium, need to "be something" to be good? Never understood this. Whats wrong with just plain old dumb fun

Filtered. You just have shit taste and probably low attention span.