2016 or Eternal? You can only choose one

2016 or Eternal? You can only choose one.

Attached: 1596806577157.png (220x313, 188.91K)

2016, it feels the most pure

Ultimate Doom

2016. I like just being able to shoot shit without needing to press the flamethrower and chainsaw buttons every so often.

OG Doom

Extermination Day
Otherwise Eternal, the extra movement mechanics and constant resource juggling actually appeal to my adhd brain

They're the same shit, nigger.

2016

2016 because if I had to choose one it would be the one that at least has the shitty snapmap.

2016 is a ‘better’ game but Eternal has better gameplay. If I’d only get to play one forever it would be Eternal.

2016.The platforming gimmick in Eternal sucks.

Obviously 2016

2016 purely because I love snapmap
If Eternal had snapmap, I would shoose it

I haven't played either one of them, which one is the most like DOOM 3?

I'd like to say 2016 because it doesn't fuck around with WHOOOOOAAAAA SO EPIC PARKOUR QUADRUPLE JUMP 17 MOBA ABILITIES SWITCH WEAPONS TO DAB WEAKPOINTS SHOT PRESS E TO GLORY KILL bullshit and is just a solid shooting gallery, but unfortunately that fat neckbeard Hugo was right - once you play Eternal, you can't go back to 2016. Everything about it is smoother, nicer, more enjoyable, the guns look, feel, and sound better, the enemy design is infinitely superior to those generic alien bugs from 2016, even the story manages to be more interesting and engaging. There's so much bullshit in Eternal, but it's undeniably the superior game.

love both but 2016 is better

2016, eternal is an unbalanced clusterfuck clouded by hugo's out of control ego.

Unreal Gold

played through the first game on normal cause i suck at shooters, should i even try eternal?

>he can't do the easiest platforming sections ever in a video game
oh man....

Are they as fun as DOOM 3?

2016 did literally everything better except enemy designs, if I could take the eternal designs and pop them into 2016 we'd be done here. Campaign is better in 2016, MP is a HELL of a lot better in 2016 (jesus fuck battlemode hugo you're a fucking retard get fired already)

Are the environments more interesting in Eternal? 2016s locales were bland as fuck for the most part. Even hell was boring to explore.

i like both a lot but 2016 is more consistently fun. eternal but is about 5 hours too long, with not quite enough good ideas to fill that time and a few of the enemies are absolute bullshit. minor point, but i think there's also far too many keybinds for a fast-paced fps. can't imagine how frustrating it would be to play eternal with a gamepad. eternal does have better music as well.

that said, this is still the difference between an 8/10 and a 9/10 game.

2016, though I loved the feel and gameplay of Eternal. I think 2016 felt a bit more solid and simpler.

2016.

I prefer the music and the industrial design of it, over the more Quake-inspired aesthetic of Eternal.

Brutal Doom

I didn't like 2016 at all. Didn't feel at all like Doom. Level design reminder me more of something C-tier like Painkiller but with a blander environment and enemy design.

It didn't resemble classic Doom at all. It's the first game I've regret buying in a long, long time. Even then I waited until it was a fiver. I've barely played in all honestly.

Should I bother downloading Eternal on GamePass? I'm not bothered if it isn't Doom classic if it does anything interesting.

if you have gamespass literally just download it and try it, it's faster paced than 2016

>like Painkiller but with a blander environment
>I've regret buying... Even then I waited until it was a fiver.
>I've barely played in all honestly.

Kys.

Eternal because 2016 was horribly repetitive and had terrible boss fights.

>unbreakable buff totem during marauder fights
>spirits
>that entire end boss fight

Holy fuck the DLC is a mess of bad ideas.

Same, desu. Only thing I liked about the game were the amazing OST and how tight the controls were. Most everything else was ok at best.

2016, but I still wouldn't call it similar.

Attached: 1477451576003.gif (1365x768, 2.62M)

I didn't enjoy 2016 at all desu. I tried playing it again and again over the years but I just can't but Eternal is one of my favorite games.

>It's the first game I've regret buying in a long, long time. Even then I waited until it was a fiver. I've barely played in all honestly.
I don't understand how someone can regret spending $5 on 2016. Its on the top 15 list of FPS games for sure. Regardless of how much more like DOOM it should have been, the game is fantastic and you're a clown and an asshat if you 'barely played'

>Eternal
Eternal feels like its own game compared to 2016 in almost every way. You have shit taste so there's no guarantee you'd like it but its much smaller in file size (paradoxically) so go ahead and try it out. Eternal is absolutely one of the best FPS games of all time.

2016 because Eternal's story went full retard as well as including needless bing bing wahoo sections and destroying the overall atmosphere of the game.