Post a game you legitimately consider to be at least a 9.5/10 in overall quality.
Post a game you legitimately consider to be at least a 9.5/10 in overall quality
Anthony Long
Landon King
BOTW, it’s not a 10 though
Zachary Kelly
Madden 95
its literally 9.5/10
William Hill
I fucking love this game
John Morris
I can think of plenty, but most of them would invite shitposters
Here's the least controversial pick I can think of
Jack Fisher
TBOI AB+
Owen Roberts
high hell
Jeremiah Lee
Bentley Robinson
Just started recently and I gotta say this though the chapter in the woods with those little fuckin mouse people was obnoxious. Also fuck Mario for falling asleep when Luigi tells his stories
Bentley Turner
Dark Souls
Andrew Brown
>but most of them would invite shitposters
let them come, it's silly to let something like that stop you when this is all a matter of opinion in terms of what you consider a bonus or malus in rating a game and why you think it deserves such a high rating. If it's just a substance-lacking shitpost like "that game's fucking garbage" then who gives a shit? Even if it's one reasoning why it's inferior properly, there can still be reasons and differing standards for why you consider it that good.
Cooper Watson
Chapter 5 is my favourite chapter in the series. The aesthetic of it just makes me so nostalgic whenever I play it.
Gavin Reed
I love Chapter 3
John Lewis
Pokémon HG/SS.
There was some shit that could've been fixed from the originals that wasn't and some shit that could've been fixed from Gen 4 in general but Heart and Soul are appropriate parts of the names. Morimoto gave a fuck despite others at GF (probably Masuda) questioning why he was putting in so much work into them.
Daniel Lopez
Terraria
Joseph Richardson
Aiden Cook
This year THPS1+2 would’ve been a 10 with better multiplayer
Andrew Reed
It's got a lot to love but I can't forgive the atrocious level curve issue being untouched
This could have been largely fixed if they tried a scaling level system for everything between Morty and Clair only
This issue brings it down to about 8.25 for me
Luis Wright
Hollow knight
Xavier Reed
Juan White
What they really need in general is badge based flags that increase the levels/Pokémon stages of trainers and wild Pokémon.
Isaiah Clark
Assuming you mean in sheer quality and overall being well made and consistently solid, rather than simply being overall the most fun or memorable :
Hollow Knight
Astro's Playroom
any COD beetwen MW1 and BO2 back when i was just a dumb kid having fun
Deep Rock Galactic
Unironically, Undertale
Deus Ex, but only back in the time it was released.
Baba is You
Yume Nikki
Pinball Space Cadet
Minefield (literally zero flaws whatsoever)
Oneshot (first playthrough(s) wise)
Joshua Howard
>Pinball Space Cadet
Good taste user
Easton Thompson
silksong when
Mason Smith
9.5/10, only because it still isn't complete
Zachary Bennett
Factorio is absolutely wonderful.
Production-wise, it's top-notch. Even in early access, the experimental branch was more stable and had fewer bugs than most games I've played. And the devs are total maniacs; sometimes you'd come up for air after playing for 3-4 hours and you'd be two or three PATCHES behind, not to mention their weekly progress reports where they'd often give neat insights as to how they're finding and fixing obscure fringe case bugs. It's easily the gold standard as to how Early Access SHOULD be done.
Gameplay-wise, it's got to be your cup of tea, but holy fuck, if you like tea, it's the best damn cup of tea out there. After you learn the basics of automating shit from A -> B, the game really opens up nicely into challenges and bottlenecks (that most of the time you've just made for yourself).
Few games are as well-made and satisfying as Factorio.
Easton Ramirez
Very confused by this list. I would've said that many of those are good, but in unconventional ways. Very poor examples when it comes to hard game design and craftsmanship. Then you also include some meme shovelware..?
Ian Rodriguez
Street Fighter 2 and its various iterations
Aiden Gutierrez
Examples of "meme shovelware"?
The only two games that could possibly fit that definition are space cadet and minefield. But for what they are, they are nearly perfect in the purpose they serve, and i wouldn't call them "shovelware" in any way. We lived in simpler times back then, anons
Levi Diaz
gothic 2 is a perfect 9,5/10
Leo Lewis
Gran Turismo 2
Kingdom Hearts II Final Mix
Ayden Jackson
>Many mission campaign with varying mission types
>huge replay value with different fighters and difficulties
>open source engine for making your own content
The best space sim video game ever
Ryan Allen
Asher Price
Trails of Cold Steel 2
Nolan Kelly
>rec thread
Fuck off, but fallout new vegas and nier gestalt
Sebastian Wright
Based