Will toledos most disappointing album ever ? What do you think anons ?
Martin and weightlifters are bangers but whole album is crap
Will Toledo new album
Its a bit dissapointing, not bad by any sense just kinda meh
I wonder what he’ll get cancelled for first, the pedo shit or just the terrible album
wtf is this pedo shit ppl are talking abt what did he do?
Anyone got a chart for what the differences are between all four versions?
Some people have always hated him anyway and then they found out about 4lung and Cate Wurtz's weird art of baby furries. 4lung is a straight up pedo and has been removed from the dedications on Twin Fantasy. Cate is more ambiguous - especially since it was for commissions - but still weird.
The description of his intent says everything: "[compete] with some of the other new pop or hip-hop acts at Coachella", i.e. make generic music for large audiences.
The best review I've seen of this said he went so far into mainstream rock, without turning to pop, that the songs turned out the most generic they ever could, and you can imagine, quite clearly, any other rock band playing them. What bothers me the most, personally, is that the lyrics are fucking awful. Really, really bad. They're all generic, overly simple, non-descriptive, bad. Will is an English major and he writes worse lyrics than before going to college.
>When the world is asleep inside
>I will wake my eyes to starlight
I can literally picture Katy Perry singing this. Reads like a line off Firework.
thats the point dumbass
>b-b-but... it's supposed to be generic and boring!!!
you can be simplistic without being boring and generic
sure but it wasn't meant to be simplistic, it was meant to be consumed like other big pop albums, and that comes with more generic and easy to understand moments
It's bad. Stop making excuses for it. It's bad writing and I'm not surprised you can't read into it since you barely know how to use punctuation.
No one in the history of the Universe ever said "I'll do X thing when the world is asleep inside my bruv." It's trash, hammy writing, forced rhymes and nonsensical lyricism.
punctuation on the internet sure is a way of judging someones credibility huh
the lyrics are not meant to be read as poetry, they're meant to work together with the music melodically and rhythmically. who cares if something doesnt make sense if it envokes the emotions its trying to envoke.
Yes, it not only represents your thoughts quite well, but it also shows how much you care about/respect writing.
>whooooooo cares
Nice non-argument that could be used to wave off any criticism. Who cares if he sings badly? It's about the instrumentals. Who cares about the instrumentals? It's about the emotion. Who cares about the emotion? It's about the lyrics. Nice shitty wheel you've built there. But here's the answer: I care, and Will should to seeing as he has albums that he wrote at 16 with better and more personal lyrics than this. By a dumb apologist all you want, but you won't enforce it on everyone else.
And finally, emotions are largely evoked by relation. Senseless rambling is confusion, not emotion, and forced rhyming is the opposite of an honest feeling.
a lot of those arguments in your 'shitty wheel' actually make sense though? it is a completely normal thing in art to pull back on some parts so other parts can be accented more. also the lyrics you posted work fine in your idea of relation, at least for me and thousands of others.
dont be mad at an artist for growing and expanding their horizons, and with that maybe pulling back on things that have become a cliche for what he or she creates. this exact same thing happened when teens of denial dropped, with people complaining about the lyrics not being extremely specific and personal, please just let the man grow out of his teenage art.
i do respect writing by the way, i'm just not interested in following every grammatical or punctual rule when in a conversation on the internet, especially since english is not my first english is not my first language. apparently what i'm saying is comprehensible enough for you to be able to respond so i dont see whats the problem in this context
Nothing was accentuated. In terms of production value, he has albums that rival this, that he made by himself, with fuller sound. In terms of songwriting and structure, he has infinitely more complex songs than the ones in this. In terms of singing, he has more aggressive vocal performances in previous records. In terms of lyrics, this is the worst. These are all undeniable, verifiable facts.
>me and thousand of others
A nice appeal to the crowd, but useless as this album's receiving heavily mixed opinions.
>dont be mad at an artist for growing and expanding their horizons
Will has somewhat changed at every album and I liked every single one of them before this. Don't assume things and use your assumptions as arguments. ToD also had Costa Concordia, which obliterates anything on MADLO.
English is also not my first language and that's neither here nor there. Now quit putting more thought into this record than William himself did and go watch Thor break the deadlift world record live.
I don't like the album, but I understand why people do. Why can't you dumb fucks understand not everyone is gonna agree on this shit. My main problems with the album are the shit production and the lyrics, but hey that's just my opinion.
he knew what he was doing with this record, the assumption that he did not is so extremely strange. the mask? the whole 'we are just having fun with it'-attitude?
also do you know anything about music production? to say that this was close to face to face or some songs on teens of denial, sure, but his older work? no
i'm also not a huge fan of this new direction but at least i understand whats happening
The production on some of the older albums are definitely better. HTLT had much better sounding synths as an example. Just because it's not low-fi doesn't mean it's better. The synths straight up ruin multiple songs. They sound like the most basic preset synth you could find turned up to 11. It's fucking ass.
>the assumption that he did not
Didn't even say this, but as for the rest, nope. Was it supposed to evoke emotion or to have fun? To rival the big pop acts (according to Will himself) or to just have silly fun? It can't be both. There was a genuine attempt here and it failed.
And yes, good music production isn't synonymous with "throwing shit at the wall and seeing what sticks". The fact that they repeat samples backwards (because that's deep) 200 times in the same song doesn't make this well produced. HTLT was infinitely more coherent and pleasant to listen to than this.
>confusing composition with production
jesus christ dude
you can actually have fun and also make a good pop record that evokes emotion! i dont see how those two things work against each other in any way, care to explain?
i'm just saying that that attitude together with the whole costume thing is a way for will to distance himself from the music, making everything less personal in maybe the most obvious way possible. i would say that that is also the case for most big pop albums, it is most of the time not actually about the artist but a character that artist is playing.
The most fun I had on the record was Can't Cool Me Down and turning it off directly after.
>composition with production
No one did that. You're kind of out of you depth here. And you also ignored this The costume is because Will is a furry. There's no news to it, no deepness. He always was a furry. He's just feeling bolder in outwardly expressing it now.
i was actually talking about the artist having fun with the process of creating art when talking about the 'we are just having fun with it'-attitude, not the listener
what synth sound they choose to pick is still composition and not production. calling me out of depth here really says something about your character.
if you read any of the press surrounding the album you can actually see will himself explain the costume thing. do you really think he just did this because he is a furry or are you just trolling at this point, what a dumb claim
That just confirms it, you're completely out of your depth. Look around, me and the other guy aren't the only ones criticizing the production on this album. Look into what it means. That's not my job.
>He tried to explain his furry costume to normal people in order to keep them around
No shit. Doesn't change the fact that he's a furry with a furry costume.
how about you explain to me what you think production is? so at least i can go on in this conversation using your definition and we can be over that.
you really think this is still a furry thing? he is going to fursuit for the first time at age 28 after trying to distance himself from the community for years? do you think daft punk have a robot fetish? do you think deadmou5e has a mouse fetish? do you not understand why any of those artists would perform wearing a mask?
No. You have people against your. It's your burden to prove why we're all wrong. You're outnumbered (and you like appealing to numbers, right?).
He is an assumed furry with a network of furries and furry fans surrounding him. This is your dumbest denial yet. He didn't try to distance himself from shit, he has lyrics alluding to being a furry, furry drawings on his covers and now a furry suit, which is also represented in more furry art. Holy fuck. You've gone beyond stupid now.
those furry lyrics, drawings and covers were all from when he was a teenager. why do you think he avoided talking about the numbered albums forever? because he is proud of them?
allright, i'll explain to you what music production is. production is the mixing and mastering of music, what sounds or instruments are used on a record are not part of the production domain but composition.
Oh, so you didn't see the cover of Twin Fantasy, both the original and re-released? You didn't see the lyrics alluding to having dog ears that "perked up", fish people and all the rest? Of praying to "dog"? You didn't see the original art for Teens of Style, after Matador? And you ignored the ending of ToD, which is about playing with a horse and walking down Dog Street? And after that you missed the references to Cate's work in the new TF? Just like you're conveniently blind to his fursuit? Because it was just the numbered albums, yeah?
Literally no point talking to someone so stupid and so deeply in denial.
How anyone is defending this crap is beyond me. "I will find strength in your power, I'll stop running like a coward, I will find you" sounds like something on a Katy Perry song. He had 4 years to make this and could barely cobble together 40 minutes of him and his Craigslist-tier backing band fucking around with weak-ass synth sounds. God awful, all of it.
>he sang about a horse so he must still be a furry
how are you calling me stupid here, and also completely skipping over the music production thing.
changing the tf cover with a rerelease sounds like a good idea to you? and besides that, you understand that there is a difference between animals and animal iconography and being a furry? if i call you 'pig-headed' or say 'hold your horses' that does not make me a fucking furry. if i make a painting with an animal on it that does not make me a furry. you spend too much time on the internet
Holy fuck. Literally the stupidest person I've ever seen talking about Will. Congratulations.
He is literally an admitted furry and a previous member of the furaffinity forums you dumbfuck. His art is commissioned from other furries.
This is my last reply because I'm convinced you're playing dumb at this point.
>literally half of those are metaphors and plays on words
im not trying to deny him ever being a furry, im just saying that i dont think this move as an artist at 28 has anything to do with him being a furry as a teenager. i have no clue what youre trying to say with that screenshot
thank you