Here's the objective top 100 RPGs of all time

>stardew valley: 51

Attached: 1401634445171.png (211x244, 72.16K)

Skyrim is 25, Morrowind is 21

>Pokemon sun and moon not only made the list, but is number 30.

Attached: 1588538764458.jpg (749x749, 111.22K)

>Front Mission 3
>94
Stopping right there

>persona 4 higher than earthbound
>pokemon yellow of all things in the top 5
Nigger what?

>3. Baldur's Gate 2
>well-written characters like Minsc
To this day I don't understand how people have deluded themselves into thinking LOL SO RANDOM XD the character is either funny or an example of good writing. Love the series, but cannot stand Minsc and the fact that he's apparently the poster boy for some reason.

>no mainline SMT

Attached: 1560699808556.png (416x489, 95.87K)

>SMT
isn't that some Persona spinoff?

Attached: 1595193930280.png (394x301, 82.22K)

>Persona 4 WAYYYY above Persona 5
Only thing they got right. Why they even listed Persona 5 is beyond me since it wasn't the list of the worst games ever made.

>Chrono Trigger #1
Yes

>Perhaps one of Pokémon Yellow's best improvements is also its most notable: Pikachu. Having the creature follow you on your journey helped further transform the monsters from simply being a team of fighters to a team of your best friends.
Have they played Heartgold/Soulsilver? I wouldn’t rate a game the 4th best in its genre because of that.

Cringe, just about everyone loved it

If Persona 5 is one of the worst games you've ever played you must not have played many games.

>wow
lmfao

lmao no. 4 is the worst persona game by far

These lists are always trash. Why not put the souls series as one entry if you feel the need to list most of them? Why list Persona 3/4/5 all as separate entries?

Because they’re all different games

user, they put pokemon yellow at 5. ignoring how shit pokemon is, theres already a superior version of the same game on GBA.
meanwhile, mystery dungeon didnt even make the fucking list.

Attached: 1571864725098.jpg (420x410, 16.8K)

>Final Fantasy VII at 52
>Final Fantasy VI at 2
Are these people fucking high?

persona 4 is there because its the game atlus has milked the most
paying up to game journos for stupid tier lists also counts as milking

Persona 3 and 5 are two spaces apart. They're different enough where you need two entries, but close enough that they're next to each-other?

to be honest, I would put a Pokemon game in the top 10. But it sure as hell wouldn't be Pokemon Yellow.

post the list i don't want give ign clicks

Yes because they’re different games, it doesn’t matter if they’re similarly placed

100EverQuest
99Wizardry 8
98Titan Quest
97Fable II
96Torchlight II
95Pillars of Eternity
94Front Mission 3
93The Bard's Tale
92Betrayal at Krondor
91Freedom Force
90Divinity: Original Sin
89Dragon Age: Inquisition
88Darkest Dungeon
87Ys Book I & II
86Kingdom Hearts II
85Chrono Cross
84Dragon Warrior VII
83Final Fantasy
82Ultima Underworld: The Stygian Abyss
81EVE Online
80Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga
79Star Ocean: The Second Story
78Illusion of Gaia
77Valkyria Chronicles
76Icewind Dale II
75The Legend of Dragoon
74Disgaea: Hour of Darkness
73The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
72Neverwinter Nights 2
71Jade Empire
70Fire Emblem Awakening
69Odin Sphere Leifthrasir
68Undertale
67Ni no Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch
66Pool of Radiance
65Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
64Lunar: Eternal Blue
63Phantasy Star Online
62Breath of Fire III
61Lunar: Silver Star Story
60Shining Force II
59Golden Sun
58Lufia II: Rise of the Sinistrals
57Tales of Vesperia
56Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars
55Shadow Hearts: Covenant
54The World Ends With You
53Phantasy Star IV
52Final Fantasy VII
51Stardew Valley

50Persona 5
49Xenoblade Chronicles
48Dragon Age: Origins
47Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3
46Grandia II
45Demon's Souls
44Xenogears
43Tales of Symphonia
42Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines
41Skies of Arcadia
40Final Fantasy IX
39Ogre Battle: The March of the Black Queen
38Fallout
37Fire Emblem
36Neverwinter Nights
35Baldur's Gate
34Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
33Dragon Quest V: Hand of the Heavenly Bride
32Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar
31Final Fantasy XII
30Pokémon Sun and Moon
29Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate
28Fallout: New Vegas
27Bloodborne
26Mass Effect
25The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
24Ultima VII: The Black Gate
23System Shock 2
22Final Fantasy IV
21The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
20Tactics Ogre: Let Us Cling Together
19EarthBound
18Final Fantasy Tactics
17Suikoden II
16Deus Ex
15Fallout 2
14Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
13Persona 4 Golden
12Dark Souls
11Mass Effect 2
10The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
09Vagrant Story
08Diablo II
07Secret of Mana
06Planescape: Torment
05World of Warcraft
04Pokémon Yellow
03Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn
02Final Fantasy VI
01Chrono Trigger

>find: mother 3
>0 results
Shit list

But now you have two spots taken up, almost next to each-other by similar games in the same series. It's just fluff.

Post a better list.

>pokemon
lmao

I’m glad that MH4U is here but I wouldn’t call it an rpg

>give these guys views on their obvious clickbait article so that they get money from their sponsors and all I get out of it is posting here about how much I disagree with it and how pretend to be outraged about how they didn't even mention some obscure and/or 20+ year old RPGs I've played?
How about I just skip all that and say that I probably don't agree with that list?

>Secret of Mana
>07

Nigga, the combat is shit and the story shallow.

>52Final Fantasy VII
Alright, I know people like to say FF7 is overrated, but this is fucking bullshit.

>Planescape Torment
>Game
It’s literally a visual novel.

>Pokemon yellow
>Not GSC

Disgusting.

This, it did not deserve to be on the SNES Classic

YOU, name the number 1 RPG of all time.

Attached: 1595183768222.png (720x720, 862.28K)

It doesn’t matter if they’re similar or in the same series, they are different games and therefore should be ranked differently. Even if they’re in the same series these games can have very different reasons why they’re good so you can’t just rank them in the same spot because it’s just not a good way to rank them.

>Secret of mothefucking Mana in the top 10
It's literally the worst game classic Square's ever made. Terribly, unfathomably bad. And it's not even bad in some obscure hard-to-discern way, the problems with the game present themselves as soon as you start playing it. This is a horrible list.

Final Fantasy VII