How come Persona 3 and 5 writing was so bad and anime compared to 4 one?

How come Persona 3 and 5 writing was so bad and anime compared to 4 one?

Attached: 1592504072671.png (498x574, 448.91K)

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=Kfkv2XCb-64
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

Adachi is completely right.
As a teenager, I thought he was wrong because he kill people. Never really focus on what he was talking about.
As a adult, I see what he say about justice is true. Innocent people go to jail all the time.
If women accuses you of rape.and you're not rich. Your life is over
If you're being physical abuse by you wife and someone call the police,guess who going to jail.

If Adachi was right he wouldn't have reacted like a bitch when he got told for all his rambling about how bad he got it, he still killed innocent people regardless like a coward.

P4 is literally the MOST anime of those two.

Can relate. I'm mostly alone cause it's easier and less stressful, but just like everybody else I don't like loneliness.
Loneliness is self-destructive and corrupting. He's a thoughtfully written character.

who did he kill

On a whole, 4 was the most down to earth of the Persona games, which is why it is so relatable. It's not 110% Demons and angels bullshit like the shin megami tensei, or completely over the top like 3/5 were.

Adachi was a dick, but he wasn't wrong either. He was frustrated because the system was broken and he couldn't do anything to fix it, eventually driving him mad.

P4 was peak kino

>If Adachi was right he wouldn't have reacted like a bitch
Bad writing.
Notice the ones told him off the most was
The son of a manager of successful supermarket
The daughter of man with a successful hotel business
A teenage genius level detective
A super popular pop idol.
Both chie and kanji didn't say much. The are also the least talented and privileged of the group.
Am I really suppose to side with bunch of privileged children?

Adachi himself was a privileged child who got handed everything in life and whined like a bitch when he wasn't treated like a king. The IT prove Adachi wrong simply by existing, and Yukiko was 100% right when she said Adachi should just kill himself.

>Adachi himself was a privileged child who got handed everything in life and whined like a bitch when he wasn't treated like a king. The IT prove Adachi wrong simply by existing, and Yukiko was 100% right when she said Adachi should just kill himself.
prove it dipshit

Didn't adachi actually put effort into becoming a policeman though?

Adaichi work hard and got nowhere. He was right it all about luck. Why do thing successful people talkbabout being blessed so much. Because they know how easily they could of fail.

What am I supposed to be doing in p3p? I'm climbing tartarus but only keep encountering recolor bosses.

based esl tellin it how it is

> and got nowhere
You won't be transfered to shithole just because of "minor mistake"
He was elite who fucked up his life, because he thought that world owns him something

>He was elite who fucked up his life, because he thought that world owns him something
>source?? trust me bro
shut the fuck up you dumb little nigger

You climb until you get to a gate and build social links between full moon bosses.

He was cop. It a high stress job. We have no idea what he did. People make mistakes all the time.

Police are elite. HOW? They get ahit pay for risking their lifes

lmao you talk like he was chief of police or some high ranking official, if he was elite he woulda been able to avoid getting sent out to bumfuck nowhere over a minor mistake, that doesnt happen to elites

now take more liberties and tell us your fanfic about how he fucked up his life because he thought the world owed him something lol

Sorry i reply to the wrong post this was mean for this

You can find a character relatable without them being right, user.
Adachi was a murderer, this makes him not right by default.
>b-b-b-but the tv kil-
sit down

Attached: 1576068579664.png (515x424, 277.39K)

Never said he wasn't a murderer. Never said he was right because he was a killer.
Just said what he about justice is right.
I ever gave u examples dumbass.

Thanks friend.

>P3 has character development, cool story and the calendar system being there made sense story and narrative vise
>P4 is a romhack of P3, but the characters are now clowns used by the devs to force out le funni and relatable scenes every single time, are all one-dimensional cardboard cutouts who suck MC's cock
>P5 is P4, but worse

You were supposed to play FES instead

what? It is a fact. The TV killed both women, NOT Adachi. There is no argument pbaby

user Adachi's loneliness and existencial issues, like feeling you're failure or wasted your youth are suppose to make him look sympathetic, but they also show that Adachi's could have choose to be a better person, improve, meet new people, in the end the game is trying to tell you that all those achievements you made, means nothing if you don't have connections or people to support you, he's what you the protagonist could become if you don't make any connections with people around you

youtube.com/watch?v=Kfkv2XCb-64

We really love in a society user

It adachi could all of that but doesn't change the fact that he still right. Having friends stop use things objectively.

Maybe it’s because tropey writin doesn’t bother me very much as long as there are believable characters and interesting concepts, but I never found myself bothered at P5’s writing. Haven’t played 3 yet

I love how Adachi discussion threads go. He truly is the best.

Attached: 1595895221403.jpg (731x1024, 84.81K)

Wooooow guys the game has good writing because there's a sad-sack like me written into it!
>As a adult
doubt

Adachi wasn’t really “right” or “wrong.” He is pretty based as a person and has a reasonable and I would argue almost admirable perspective and philosophy, but what he did with it was shitty and not constructive. I still like him a lot overall, but it’s not like he’s a big hero or some soulless villain

It must be exhausting to have to view the world the way that you do.