Yes they are but they're no longer what they were. Basically every major Kibbutz either fell apart due to people leaving so they could marry outside the Kibbutz or the people deciding to hire people from outside. So hiring people for a wage so they can exploit that worker, that sounds exactly like a company to me. In the end it was an interesting piece of history but it either dissolved or became massive companies that exploit non-Kibbutz workers for profit.
We're meant to be left wing here buddy an ideology that promotes the cause of a single race of people at the detriment of the another isn't welcome.
Most Kibbutz were basically closed communities that didn't even allow marriage outside of the commune. So I hazard a guess they mostly ended up being ethno-communes.
Luis Johnson
Zionism is more complex than just that it's justifiable unlike other forms of ethno centrism.
Dominic Campbell
Justifiable in what way? Because of the Holocaust? Because of their treatment during the Diaspora? Well shit if it's because of that then you would support Celtic nationalism, Black nationalism, and Greek nationalism. No ethno-centric ideology can co-exist with far left politics otherwise it begins to function like Italian Fascism.
