Who started this meme and why did everyone pick up on it? Was there any significant marxist or anarchist theorist who worded it this way?
It seems dumb to me as it implies one type of property is legitimate while the other isn't.
Can't we simply use "property" and "possesions" instead?
"private" vs "personal" property
Dominic Hill
Other urls found in this thread:
Nathan Cook
It's a distinction that exists under english common law: since Marx and Engels knew english history and law quite well they took it from there.
John Morgan
Also the concept in general is retarded, your toothbrush is mine to use.
Thomas Gonzalez
Your boipussy is mine to use, bend over bitch.
James Allen
Okay but remember I get to use yours when you're done, and I always go in
Dry
Jacob Peterson
Honestly if you haven’t started saying “commercial property” instead of “private property property” whenever talking to normies you need to get your shit together.
Dylan Hill
why did you post this
Jason Walker
Is my house personal or private? Thanks.
Christopher Diaz
Charles Lee
Personal. If you rent it out then it’s private.
Oliver Flores
Reminder that rent is theft.
Eli Williams
Rightists have low lQ and will never understand this concept.
Lincoln Sanchez
Are you acknowledging the reliability in lQ?
Hudson Thomas
This is exactly what Proudhon did, but then I guess no one bothered to listen.
Samuel Allen
to be fair, proudhon was shit
Jackson Wood
Yeah but his distinction between owner and possessor was good, and is still prominent in socialist thought today.
Adam Clark
I want to be used by the entire commune
Camden Bailey
for all intents and purposes it's personal. but if your house is a colossal property, people might want to colectivize it in socialism. Still you wouldn't probably be able to take care of a mansion alone without hiring anyone.
Logan Nguyen
Its just red-liberals who don't want to share their anime figure stands.
Isaac Williams
I say corporate property just because so many people already have a negative association to the word
Luke Adams
I'm pretty sure private property always meant the means of production, since feudal times. The whole "Private property = your TV" shit is something modern liberals made up
Ryan Bailey
if i wear my shoes to work then those shoes are the people's capital. If I'm not efficient with the people's capital they are legally allowed to send me to the human optimization chambers
Parker Parker
Probably because Proudhon was french, english can be weirder than french sometimes, especially common law. The difference is just linguistic.
Eli Baker
semantics tbh
how do we differ say, a bike or computer from a corporation or organization? without using orthodox terminology
I think complexity distinguishes the two.
Personal property requires a direct, physical access, devoid of social and financial middle men or third parties
Joseph Johnson
Private property has always meant means of production.
Its only in very recent history that people started calling their personal stuff "private".
Nicholas Campbell
Mostly just using lQ to trigger rightists.
It works every time.
Brayden Carter
Colton Miller
Is this a joke post? Or are you truly this fucking stupid?
Thats the entire point of Marxism!!!!! Marxism rejects private property, and instead demands public ownership of porperty! I seriously can not imagine the sort of quibbly mess that is inside your skull. I dont even think a maggot would eat the disgusting pile of shit between your ears.
Hooo. Hoo wow. Have you ever heard of KARL MARX!? Perhaps you may have read a little book called the Communist Manifesto?
Levi Williams
The distinction exists out of necessity.
Mason Jones
',:^)