Basically, they say that it was deorganised and undisciplined
"Such was the turmoil in some companies that a commission of the Barcelona CNT issued on May 17, 1937 a report quite critical of the performance of some collectives: "The excessive concern to collectivize everything, especially companies that had monetary reserves, have awakened among the masses a utilitarian and petty bourgeois spirit […] Considering all collectivity as a particular property, and not as a usufruct only, the interests of the rest of the community have been abstracted. The collectivized companies have only worried about their liabilities, producing an imbalance in the finances of the other companies "(cited BROUÉ: 79)"
How is it the favorite example of anarchism is garbage in reality?
Blog is not a reliable source, but I agree thought. Playing anarchism during civil war in during which your enemy is supported by most of major powers and has technological and numeral advantage is pure idiocy. Besides, anarcho communism is about getting rid of unfair hierarchies and inhumane exploitation of earth, rather than disorganization o decentralization. Besides, anarchism doesn't grow on tress, people need to be educated and inspired by good example.
People in general are dumb, thought. Hence why capitalism exists in the first place, and majority of humanity are de-facto slaves.
Jonathan Rodriguez
Todos los hispanohablantes aca respondan "la CNT no hizo nada malo" para ver cuantos somos.
Dominic Green
did google translate it well?
All Spanish speakers here reply "the CNT did nothing wrong" to see how many we are.
Henry Bell
La CNT no hizo nada malo. La única iglesia que ilumina es la que está ardiendo.
And practise is more important than theory, so this kind of stuff justify the bullshit that anarchism is crap, unrealistic and nonsense… Which is sad
But I was dissappointed, I always Heard that the CNT was good.
Pero si en el blog pone todo lo que hicieron mal
Luis Nguyen
La CNT hizo mil cosas mal, especialmente tras la muerte de Durruti (posiblemente a mano de otros miembros que estaban descontenros con su apoyo al frente popular y pensaban que era un "estalinista" infiltrado) Su gestion del frente de Aragón fue desastrosa, perdieron cada batalla que lucharon solos a pesar del masivo apoyo soviético (que se centro sobre todo en dicho frente), y sin nisiquiera hablar de los sucesos de Barcelona.
Ciertos sectores de la CNT tubieron una posicion infantil y reaccionaria que daño el esfuerzo de guerra, y esto te lo puede decir cualquiera incluyendo yo que mi bisabuelo fue de la FAI
Va pero si que era una mierda loko Y ni si quiera han entrado en los anarcas abriendo otro puto frente contra la República en plena guerra civil contra el fascismo en fin
